Whilst the majority of people here probably would opt for am untapered Raiders-style hat, there are some fans of the TOD tapered style, too.
Basically, its how you feel and what you like that counts, of course. The hat does look pretty cool in those pics, but it looks like it might be just a bit small for you?
If you have decided to upgrade, that hat would be a good one to keep as a collectors item and give you a good idea of the size you should choose next time.
BTW, closer to home than Todds, you can get the same HJ from
www.indyfedora.com or a very nice Akubra Federation, which lends itself well to the TOD look, from
www.hatsdirect.com. Of the two, the Akubra is the cheapest option but one heck of a hat for the money.
Cool that you are so close to Wested. You could get fitted by Peter in person, if you ever decided to go that route.
Regards
Al