Adam, First of all Congratulations on such an excellent showing at the W.W.A.C. convention. The John and Vi Brady award especially is a very high honor, you should be very proud of that accomplishment and recognition. What kind of whip did they present you with?
Olive oil has long been used as a leather lubricant and conditioner. You can even melt beeswax into it to make it more like a paste or balm. A little tends to goes a long way though and it is known to soften leather. The main trouble with olive oil is that oxygen, heat, and light will cause it to go rancid and like all vegetable oils it will eventually go bad. In addition to the foul smell, it becomes sticky an gummy. As with neatsfoot oil, light oils (The kind that are liquid at room temperature) can easily over saturate leather causing the fibers to swell and loosen, weakening it in a similar way that water can. If you use too much you might get mushy, oily leather. Not to mention the fact that it is more likely to hold moisture which can start to rot the leather and act as a food source it making mold a potential issue as well. Vermin are also attracted to the smell. I have heard that light oils also tend to evaporate faster out of the leather, so you have to reapply them more often. Basically, when it comes to leather if you have to use oil, a little is ok in moderation but a lot is very bad. The same can be said with hard fat type leather dressings as well though, you dont want to over dress your whip.
There many schools of though on what will and won't hurt a leather whip when it comes to leather dressings and oils. With all the things I’ve heard of people using on their whips, from various tallow recipes, steak fat to neatsfoot oil and even neutrogena soap, nothing really surprises me any more. Some people (including a few well known whipmakers, will even tell you not to use anything with petroleum based products (I.e. Pecards) on leather whips. For the most part though whips tend to go the distance better, not so much due to what the owner is conditioning them with (Within reason), but rather that the owner is conscious and consistent about taking care of them.
Ben Hughes being a five time Australian whip cracking champion and unquestionably one of the best sport crackers in the world only tells me the he knows how to crack whips and he know how to get the most out of them. Not that he’s an expert on leather care or keeping his whips in great shape for years and years to come. Now I don’t mean that disrespectfully
![Happy :)](./images/smilies/IndySmile.gif)
I only know him by reputation and that is a good one at that, but I don’t know where he leaned that trick, the use of olive oil tends to be one of those old timers tricks, before they knew better and didn't always have 'the right stuff' available to use.
About twenty years ago I had an old latigo bullwhip, it was nothing special, but it was tough and was my primary whip at the time. I had been using for a few years already with out giving it much looking after (this was long before the internet and information wasn’t so easily available back then). It was getting dry and looking a bit rough so I asked a local “old timer” who seemed to know a thing or two about leather care, what I could use on it, he said just rub the entire whip down real good with vegetable oil. Well I did just that and it worked great the first few times, it added some weight, darkened the leather up and made it look shiny and nice. However the oil in the leather eventfully went bad and the leather started to stink of rancid vegetable oil. It also seemed to speed the deterioration of the whip as the leather started to break down faster after I oiled up, at least faster then it would have if I just left it alone. Well I cleaned it up as best I could but stopped using that whip for those reasons. It wasn’t till a few years later when talked with David Morgan, and learned about Pecards products that I was able to stop the damage I had done, and stabilize and restore the leather enough to keep it as a heirloom of sorts.
Now, I don’t consider my self the know it all source on leather care or whips so I won’t contradict you or Ben. I do know what works for me and I am sorry to say, I wouldn’t pay 400 dollars for that whip knowing that it had been soak with olive oil, no matter how well it cracked. That might sound a bit harsh, but a great whip maker should be able to make a well-balanced whip that cracks with fluidity and ease with out using a short cut like weighting it with a lot of oil. I have never heard of Joe Strain, Mike Murphy or Janine Fraser etc. oiling up their whips like that and I would be surprised if I did. Certainly everyone has their own personal preference on how a whip should feel, some like them light and quick others heavy, but that’s why you have a whip maker work with you to make a whip that fits your individual needs. Oils and dressing should only have to be used to keep the leather in good shape. With that said, They are your whips so do with them as you please, if it works for you and there are not ill effect, thats great more power too you and if it doesn’t work out you can always make new ones. If someone else is thinking about they trying this with a new $800 Morgan bullwhip to make it look more like Indy’s or use it on a $700 matched pair of Mike Murphy stockwhips to try to get a lil extra oomph out of them, then its something I would recommend investigate deeper by talking to other whip handlers and makers first before just jump in feet and try it. Anyway, that’s just my 2 cents on the matter for what ever its worth. Hopefully I didn’t ruffle any feathers as that was not my intent.
All the best
Dan