Club Obi Wan

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 12:25 pm**

Other shots of the buckle from Raiders

I've received another sample today that is identical to my original buckle I bought from the leather shop in Portland.

I included a side by side with comparison to the keppler buckle
(I also threw in the Siegel for the fun of it.)

You can see from the Raiders comparison pic that these buckles match
more then a few the scenes. As both Sergei stated and I agreed, there were obviously a few different buckles used over the course of the film.

At this point, unless something else comes along, I'm offering this new buckle as an option if people want.

I'm waiting to hear back on the final price, but from the wholesale list I have, plan on about $1.00 each which will include shipping.
(I'm not sure if I will be able to buy them wholesale.)

This is who I have originally listed and amounts:
(If you don't see your name, PM me)

Riverwind: 5
skywlkrinc: 1
JerseyJones: 2
indybill: 5
Indiana: 1

Paulcrastination: 5
English Adventurer: 2
IndyBlues: 5
Renderking Fisk: 1
Panama Tom Jr: 1
Indiana Grendel: 5 or 10
dkwd 2
Indiana_Dudley: 3

Robert Duke: 1
Swindiana: 3
toshberry: 2
antiquity collector: 1
Starman Jone: 2
Robert Duke: 1
Tollan: 5
Trevelyan: 2

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 12:47 pm**

Sounded more promising when it was a 'soid lead'.

Sorry to be goofy... just need to ease some agrivation.

Mike

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 12:59 pm**

PM sent!

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 1:00 pm**

Shows you how cold my drive in today was....my frozen brain kept wondering 'why would ANYBODY want a buckle made out of 'solid lead'!? Sheesh!

Regards. Michaelson

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 1:43 pm**

Michaelson wrote:Shows you how cold my drive in today was....my frozen brain kept wondering 'why would ANYBODY want a buckle made out of 'solid lead'!? Sheesh! Regards. Michaelson

Well I suppose if you're Superman, it would definitely be an advantage!

BTW People, in your PMs let me know which you prefer.
My thought is that I'm going to get the ones from Seigel.

Dalexs

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 1:46 pm**

PM sent!

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 3:52 pm**

Dalexs,

Great comparison photos. The one from Seigel definately looks like
a winner! PM sent.

Regards,
Indybill

Posted: **Wed Jan 28, 2004 9:01 pm**

Pic aint a-working, but I am very interested!

I J

Posted: **Thu Jan 29, 2004 3:01 am**

Dalexs wrote:I .. Sergei originally though it was too big.
I disagree based on the screen shot.

...

Well I have looked at a lot of screen shots. It does seem to vary. What I meant by the Siegel buckle is that the frame was on the thick side. It should resemble the Keppler frame thiness. There are contradictory scenes where the buckle is not as thick as what is posted here.

I just got out the tape measure and measured the Keppler buckle. On the inside dimension:
- 1" x 1 1/8"

Outside dimension:
- 1 5/16" x 1 7/16"

The buckle's inside dimension has to be big enough to accomodate the 1" leather strap.

Hope this helps...
-Sergei

Posted: **Thu Jan 29, 2004 9:58 am**

These are listed as 1" buckles so they should accomodate a 1" strap.
If they don't I'll just send them back.

In terms of the contradictory scenes, I watched a number of scenes that showed the buckle looking like the above image.

All throughout Cairo, you get glimpses of the buckle and it definitely looks like that. The scene above is from the flying wing fight sequence when they are under the plane.

I'm not trying to diss on Lee's product. God knows he's done wonders for all of us. And I don't doubt that there are inconsistencies, as there are with pretty much all of the gear, but close up pictures don't lie.

Now, does one like the way it is going to look on their bag? Who knows, thats going to be a personal preference.

All I know, is enough people contacted me to make it worth buying a bag of 100.

So I'll let you all know when it comes in.

Steve

Posted: **Thu Jan 29, 2004 11:53 am**

I'm in for a few.

David

Posted: **Thu Jan 29, 2004 12:15 pm**

Dalexs wrote: All I know, is enough people contacted me to make it worth buying a bag of 100.

Who is on your list so far?

Actually, just making sure you got my PM the other day letting you know I wanted a couple...

Thanks!

Posted: **Thu Jan 29, 2004 3:52 pm**

Just got off the phone with Siegals of Calif. They are going to send me a catalog and a sample (going in the mail today). That way, before I commit a chunck of change, I can see what it looks like on a strap.

The price may be closer to 1.20 each +shipping, because I can't buy wholesale. I'm working that out. A price break comes at 125 pieces.
I will probably not get that many.

You will see that I've updated the above image.

The Goldbergs (or shoeeyelets.com) buckle is a no. They don't stock the one I originally showed that was similar to kepplers. I would need a minimum order of 2000 to get it made.
They do stock the one shown. Yes, it says Hush Puppy on it. The fit is alittle tight and I don't like the overall look of it.
So stop calling Francis, because that's the one you're going to get as a sample.

I should have an update mid next week.

Posted: **Thu Jan 29, 2004 5:24 pm**

All this talk of a perfect buckle has me seeing them in my sleep. Anyway, I was watching LC last night and noticed that the buckle gets pretty beat up while Indy's hanging from the tank. Maybe if we just bend and beat the heck out of all our gear, we can finally get it perfect

(sorry it's so grainy, I just took a picture of the TV)

Posted: **Wed Feb 04, 2004 9:21 pm**

Just curious if there was any updates concering the buckle?

Also, I was wondering if the buckles you are getting have the small indention that the belt hole bar sits in that keeps it from sliding around when it is attached...(For lack of better words!)...

You can see the indention in the HushPuppy/Goldbergs buckle, but the Keppler and Noel Howard buckle are smooth all the way around...

Thanks!

Posted: **Thu Feb 05, 2004 9:31 am**

The one from Seigal does not have the indent.

Regards,
Indybill

Posted: **Thu Feb 05, 2004 9:37 am**

I spoke with them the middle of last week and they were sending me out a catalog and a sample of the buckle. I decided to get the sample before I dropped to much cash on something that might not be right.

I am still waiting the sample to come in. If I don't get by theend ofthis week, I will probably just go ahead and order the minimum amount and hope for the best.

And as Bill said, they do not have the indent for the tongue.

I let you guys know as soon as I do.

Dalexs

Posted: **Fri Feb 06, 2004 12:11 am**

I also got 2 samples from Goldberg this week with the HushPuppy stamped on it with the indention. I set about grinding it down and got it all smoothed out but.... then I noticed it's a shade small... about 7/8" wide x 3/4" .... so it's just a squeeze below 1"

I'd be interested in buying a Siegel's buckle when you get them if you are going to order them.... hope they are the right one.

Keep on cracking a smile.

Robert Duke

Posted: **Fri Feb 06, 2004 12:32 am**

I'm interested too in case it turns out well if it isn't too much of a trouble.
I'm planning on making straps for my other three bags and this one does look pretty good!

Regards
Swindina

Posted: **Mon Feb 09, 2004 12:44 pm**

I'm interested too. By the way, where is the store in CA? I might be able to go in if it's in LA.

On a side note, I was looking thru my reference to bash a new hat and found a few pics from Raiders where his buckle is bent in a "V" shape. Could be due to filming or they might have had different buckles on the various bags used.

Rob

Posted: **Tue Feb 10, 2004 11:25 am**

Dalexs wrote: BTW People, in your PMs let me know which you prefer.
My thought is that I'm going to get the ones from Spiegel.

Spiegel?

I couldn't help but hopping on that one.

I know what you meant though.

Finding this buckle has been like seeking the Lost Grail. Even Keppler's doesn't look "perfect". Choose wisely. It appears the Siegel's is the perfect one. I hope that it is not stamped. That darn Goldberg one would've been right if it didn't have Hushpuppy and the tongue indention stamped and if it would've been a hair larger. They are misrepresenting the ad since it is not truly a 1" buckle.

The pictures of the one Indy was wearing that was bent represents the Conway style of buckle. From the side you can see it's bent in the middle. Seeing it front on in other pics it doesn't appear to have that curve. I ordered a Conway 1" buckle and don't like it. So, looking forward to the Siegel if it's good.

Robert Duke

Posted: **Fri Feb 13, 2004 2:10 pm**

Posted: **Sat Feb 14, 2004 11:14 am**

Im going to say about the same thing as Dale. Kind of on the fence here....it looks raiders "ish" but.....hmmmm. Anybody else?

Indy J

Im a big help, huh?

Posted: **Sat Feb 14, 2004 2:41 pm**

After sleeping on the thought, it just looks too big, which is a shame because I thought this was the one. One thought I did have was on the 7/8 in. buckle that was discussed before. I found that if you carefully hammer a buckle, you can actually shrink the length, while increasing the width. I tried this on a buckle that was much too long and it ended up being the right length, but almost a quarter inch too wide, then I accidentally broke it in half

Anyway, just a thought.

Posted: **Mon Feb 16, 2004 2:34 pm**

How about this....?

http://www.thomasregister.com/olc/smart ... ectemp.htm

I J

EDIT< Eh, maybe not....nevermind.

-------------------
or this:

http://www.heritan.com/Merchant2/mercha ... allpurpose

Too bad its 1 1/4" dangit.

Posted: **Mon Feb 16, 2004 2:43 pm**

AHA!

how about this?

Comes in 1"....
http://www.heritan.com/Merchant2/mercha ... allpurpose

I J

Posted: **Mon Feb 16, 2004 5:55 pm**

Two things to say, based on some feedback and looking at the buckle all weekend, I've decided NOT to go with the buckle from Siegels.
I just don't think it is right. It's close, but just not right.

That one above from Heritan is interesting if it is a solid cast buckle and not stamped. Anyone want to contact them and get a sample or buy a couple?

Sorry this didn't work out, but I'm sure we'll find it someday.
Let the quest continue!

Dalexs

Posted: **Mon Feb 16, 2004 10:21 pm**

Bummer about seigels, the quest continues. Thanks for the leg work!! Ill try to get a sample of this one, and post my findings here.

I J

Posted: **Tue Feb 17, 2004 9:07 am**

Is it hard to get a sample from these guys? I might try it but I'm not sure if they will ship to Sweden free of charge.

Thanks for the hard work Dalexs. I think we share the same taste in buckles and I would probably feel the same way about it.

Swindy

Posted: **Tue Feb 17, 2004 5:46 pm**

Dang! I really thought the Seigal would be the one, but you're right
the thing just isn't quite the right proportions. It needs to be shorter,
like a garrison buckle, than it is wide. And the search continues.......

Regards,
Indybill

Posted: **Tue Feb 17, 2004 6:01 pm**

Yeah, a 1" garrison buckle would be perfect, kinda like this one

Too bad it only comes in 1 1/2" & 1 3/4"

Posted: **Tue Feb 17, 2004 10:52 pm**

Wow, that is perfect. Harridans wont send me a sample, so Ill just have to buy one. Ill try to order it sometime this week.

Indy J

Posted: **Wed Feb 18, 2004 12:07 am**

Check out the buckles at http://www.tandyleather.com/products.as ... genumber=2. The 69 cent buckle looks decent.

Posted: **Wed Feb 18, 2004 1:10 am**

Scratch my last post, the cheapest shipping I can get is $10 for one lousy buckle. Do we have any gearheads in Canada?

IJ

Posted: **Wed Feb 18, 2004 6:06 am**

Guys,

I'm talking to a guy in the UK, who has many years of replica work experience, and is a leather craftsman. He seems pretty sure he can match the buckle from a UK source, especially as the original was English.

The www.bucklesexpress.com UK source I posted in an earlier thread didn't work out. Thin pressed buckles I'm afraid....

More details to follow, keep fingers crossed.

ID

Posted: **Wed Feb 18, 2004 10:47 am**

Starman Jones wrote:Check out the buckles at http://www.tandyleather.com/products.as ... genumber=2. \
The 69 cent buckle looks decent.

The problem with that style of buckle is the roller along the top rail.
It would have to come off and then you would find that it is set
over/in an indent along that top rail. Some of those styles you can't even remove the roller.

Indiana_Dudley wrote:I'm talking to a guy in the UK, who has many years of replica work experience, and is a leather craftsman. He seems pretty sure he can match the buckle from a UK source, especially as the original was English.

That would be great if you could come up with something.
I did see a couple over at http://www.abbeysaddlery.co.uk/
(but the site doesn't always work well, hence no pictures.)
If you could find something in a 1" size that looks like the above
Garrison we'd be in good shape.

Good luck.

Posted: **Tue Feb 24, 2004 7:58 am**

Hi Dalexs and everyone, here's some that may prove useful?
The buckles with the rollers I included as it appears they are not inset, but sit above the buckle, so could probably be pulled off with plyers. All are 25mm or 1 inch.
What do you think?

Posted: **Tue Feb 24, 2004 9:42 am**

I like the middle one, as long as it's not a stamped and the roller is in fact not riding on an indent.

The bottom has the right shape, but like the Aplus buckles, it looks stamped, so not very sturdy, and won't fit all straps (thickness).

I have found a few sources here that supply ones like in the top picture but without the roller. Which would be basically the same as Kepplers buckle.

As soon as I see the samples, I'll post it.

Dalexs

Posted: **Tue Feb 24, 2004 10:37 pm**

I like all three of those.....if it looks like the Keppler, it works for me!

I J

Posted: **Tue Feb 24, 2004 11:39 pm**

I agree, those look nice. The roller doesn't really bother me either, since it shows up in Temple of Doom

Posted: **Wed Feb 25, 2004 10:31 am**

The top one isn't quite the right proportions.
The middle looks like it's the right shape, but
also appears to be stamped, stamped is not
good.

Regards,
Indybill

Posted: **Wed Feb 25, 2004 1:01 pm**

I'm up in Canada. I have a Tandy about 2 blocks from work - it turns out - I just found it two weeks ago. We no longer have a Heritan in Winnipeg though.

David

Posted: **Thu Feb 26, 2004 10:35 pm**

One more bump.

Posted: **Fri Feb 27, 2004 3:16 am**

Dalexs wrote:...You can see from the Raiders comparison pic that these buckles match
more then a few the scenes. As both Sergei stated and I agreed, there were obviously a few different buckles used over the course of the film.

..

I'm not going to say, I told you so. ) But you did kind of hesitate with my statement. I do like the thiner frame buckle. )

Posted: **Sat Feb 28, 2004 7:23 am**

FYI

I do still have the guy in the UK looking hard. According to his last mail he should soon have a collection of 1" buckles from a selection of UK trade suppliers. These will be based on photos from this forum and screenshots.

I don't have a date on when these will arrive, and I don't want to hassle him. But I will post as soon as possible.

ID.

Posted: **Fri Mar 12, 2004 12:11 am**

OK, heres something promising -

This buckle that I posted before has it all:
-Nickle
-1"x 1"
-rounded edges
-no divit for the center post

Ive been emailing back and forth, and have finally gotten them to send me a couple without spending $10 on shipping - Ill update here, or start a new post when they arrive.

I J

Posted: **Sat Mar 27, 2004 2:11 am**

This buckle finally arrive after a week and half, and after getting charged the full $10 for shipping. And it stinks. The edges are way to rounded. :evil: :evil:

-I J

Posted: **Mon Apr 05, 2004 11:02 am**

indiana_dudley wrote:FYI

I do still have the guy in the UK looking hard. According to his last mail he should soon have a collection of 1" buckles from a selection of UK trade suppliers. These will be based on photos from this forum and screenshots.

I don't have a date on when these will arrive, and I don't want to hassle him. But I will post as soon as possible.

ID.

At last.....

I have what could be the first buckle that comes close from the UK source. I am inquiring if this same buckle comes in nickle, but your thoughts so far please....

<img src="http://www.lost-ark.net/images/buckle.jpg">

Posted: **Mon Apr 05, 2004 11:11 am**

It looks pretty much spot on I would say. It would be great if it comes in nickel.
Does that white string come off though?

Regards,
Swindiana

Posted: **Mon Apr 05, 2004 12:32 pm**

Hey that's a great looking buckle.
If they come in nickel we'll have to do a group buy
amongst the COW members.

Regards,
Indybill

Club Obi Wan

Bag Strap Buckles Updated!

Bag Strap Buckles Updated!

Re: Solid lead on Bag Strap Buckles!

belt me!

A Minor Update

Re: Bag Strap Buckles Revisited