Page 1 of 1
Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:28 pm
by winrichwhips
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6I_ESNuLwGA" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
I've been wanting to try this for a while now. There's no cable in the whip, just parachute cord with the core left in and a really beefy fall.
-Adam
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:41 pm
by TREX
winrichwhips wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6I_ESNuLwGA" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
I've been wanting to try this for a while now. There's no cable in the whip, just parachute cord with the core left in and a really beefy fall.
-Adam
Adam, Love it!!! Thank for that video, That was Awesome!! I did that all the time when I was twelve! (of course I only weighed like 80 pounds) I think Today, me being a big fat ###, I would definitely need steel cable reinforced whip LOL!
-T.Rex
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:54 pm
by winrichwhips
I figured more people must've tried this considering once I really tried it I didn't find it that hard. The only hard part, if you can call it hard, was messing around with the design of the fall so that it would be long enough to wrap and hold, and strong enough to hold my weight. I talked with Joe Strain and he said he tried it when he was a kid and broke the fall on his whip.
I recall that IndyMcFly posted a video a while back, but I don't think he did the wrapping and the swinging in one shot. Maybe someone out there can fill me in on what exactly McFly did in his video.
My goal is to submit it to MythBusters since I don't think they covered any whip stunts when they did all the other Indiana Jones myths.
I had a kid post a comment saying that this whip was impractical, though I'd say it can do everything that any 10-12 ft bullwhip can do. It's certainly more practical than a whip with cable running the whole length of it.
-Adam
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 2:14 pm
by riku1914
I've thought about making a whip with 3 strands of paracord running down the center like you did, bu what I would have done is
made the paracord as the fall, which doesn't grip well, bit I'd probably put them in the 3 strand flat plait for the fall area.
This is cool
Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 2:58 pm
by Jedirun
winrichwhips wrote:I figured more people must've tried this considering once I really tried it I didn't find it that hard. The only hard part, if you can call it hard, was messing around with the design of the fall so that it would be long enough to wrap and hold, and strong enough to hold my weight. I talked with Joe Strain and he said he tried it when he was a kid and broke the fall on his whip.
I recall that IndyMcFly posted a video a while back, but I don't think he did the wrapping and the swinging in one shot. Maybe someone out there can fill me in on what exactly McFly did in his video.
My goal is to submit it to MythBusters since I don't think they covered any whip stunts when they did all the other Indiana Jones myths.
I had a kid post a comment saying that this whip was impractical, though I'd say it can do everything that any 10-12 ft bullwhip can do. It's certainly more practical than a whip with cable running the whole length of it.
-Adam
I believe Indy Mcfly's video was satire. I think he swung off of a cable rather than his whip and posted another video about making the first one.
That is the first time I have ever seen anyone actually swing off of a whip like Indy. Although like you said, someone else must have done it.
That is a really cool video. Thanks for sharing.
---
-
Dr. Jones
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 5:50 pm
by knibs7
I'm just glad that it has finally been proven that you CAN release the whip with the "flick" at the end (TOD style)
Cool video Adam!
Kyle
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 6:24 pm
by binkmeisterRick
Alright, who wants to lend me their David Morgan so I can try this myself?
I always figured it
could be done, but after owning a nice whip, came to realize whether or not it
should be done!
Good to see a demo of this principle in practice, but I'd venture to say it would destroy or harm a nice whip not designed for such a task.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 6:54 pm
by knibs7
binkmeisterRick wrote:Alright, who wants to lend me their David Morgan so I can try this myself?
You can use mine... but I WILL need a $3000 deposit
binkmeisterRick wrote: I'd venture to say it would destroy or harm a nice whip not designed for such a task.
Maybe Indy's was supposed to have been designed to swing on... even though we all now know what the whips he used were made of...
Kyle
Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 8:29 pm
by Jedirun
I just watched the video again. I have got to say thank you. This let's me watch the movies again without that nagging feeling that the whip swinging is impossible.
---
-
Dr. Jones
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 9:29 pm
by riku1914
Well.. my brother saw me watching this video, I just finished making him a nylon stockwhip, I came outside to crack my bullwhip,
to see him swinging on it. I specifically told him not to, but he's been kinda deaf today. He ruined the thing, plaiting was nice,
uniform and firm, now it's all separated and loose, it cracked so loud and so fast earlier, now i doesn't. In fact, I timed myself
doing a volley for 15 seconds early, I got 56 cracks. very fast. Now it's just junk. I put so much time into this. I'm not blaming you
adam, just venting if not anything else.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 9:37 pm
by Hollowpond
That was awesome!!!! I'm sitting here watching this video with my oldest son and he will NOT stop bugging me to buy him one of these whips!!! He loved it more than I did. As always, great job Adam.
Travis
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 9:48 pm
by winrichwhips
riku1914 wrote:Well.. my brother saw me watching this video, I just finished making him a nylon stockwhip, I came outside to crack my bullwhip,
to see him swinging on it. I specifically told him not to, but he's been kinda deaf today. He ruined the thing, plaiting was nice,
uniform and firm, now it's all separated and loose, it cracked so loud and so fast earlier, now i doesn't. In fact, I timed myself
doing a volley for 15 seconds early, I got 56 cracks. very fast. Now it's just junk. I put so much time into this. I'm not blaming you
adam, just venting if not anything else.
Sorry the whip got ruined
I tried explaining in the video how I made this whip different from other whips in the hopes that people wouldn't watch it and try to swing on whatever whip they had on hand. I guess I should have added "don't try this at home" though I'm not sure that ever works.
-Adam
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 1:28 pm
by Holmes
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 4:07 pm
by riku1914
winrichwhips wrote:riku1914 wrote:Well.. my brother saw me watching this video, I just finished making him a nylon stockwhip, I came outside to crack my bullwhip,
to see him swinging on it. I specifically told him not to, but he's been kinda deaf today. He ruined the thing, plaiting was nice,
uniform and firm, now it's all separated and loose, it cracked so loud and so fast earlier, now i doesn't. In fact, I timed myself
doing a volley for 15 seconds early, I got 56 cracks. very fast. Now it's just junk. I put so much time into this. I'm not blaming you
adam, just venting if not anything else.
Sorry the whip got ruined
I tried explaining in the video how I made this whip different from other whips in the hopes that people wouldn't watch it and try to swing on whatever whip they had on hand. I guess I should have added "don't try this at home" though I'm not sure that ever works.
-Adam
it doesn't, iv'e tried who knows how many things mythbusters have done
Well Two people specifically told him not to and he did anyway, I don't think a third would have made any difference.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 4:14 pm
by mrkaboom
ha ha what a gallah and what a video!
that was wicked adam put a smile on my face!
Mk
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 4:35 pm
by kwad
All right Adam!!
You now go down in Indy fan history
I think Adam and Jamie would say...................
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 4:49 pm
by riku1914
You could swing from just about any whip, you'd just ruin it, that's all. I now have first hand experience from a 60 pound kid ruining
a nylon whip, so now I can tell people that I have seen it happen, and it's not just rumor or heresay.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 4:54 pm
by Indyzane
That's very cool! Thank for sharing!
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2011 6:12 pm
by starks_6
When I was around 12 or 13 (26 now) my dad went to disneyland and brought me back, what was at the time, an indiana jones whip... looked nothing like it
.
In any case I used to whip that around low tree branches and swing quite successfully. Absolutely destroyed what was a cheaply made 4 plait whip anyhow. completely stretched the plaits apart near the handle. You could get a finger between them.
But when you grow up a bit and get a proper whip you learn not to make that mistake again!!
Ah to be a kid.....
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Tue Aug 16, 2011 3:36 am
by barry
starks_6 wrote:When I was around 12 or 13 (26 now) my dad went to disneyland and brought me back, what was at the time, an indiana jones whip... looked nothing like it
.
In any case I used to whip that around low tree branches and swing quite successfully. Absolutely destroyed what was a cheaply made 4 plait whip anyhow. completely stretched the plaits apart near the handle. You could get a finger between them.
But when you grow up a bit and get a proper whip you learn not to make that mistake again!!
Ah to be a kid.....
love the vid i knew it was possiable but dont want to risk my whip but if you know how to make them well why not thanks for the swing
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2011 3:47 pm
by jeanfifi
You Indiana Winrich, or Adam Jones
Excellent!!!!
thanks for sharing
JP
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2011 4:41 pm
by whipcracker
Viva Cinco de Mayo!
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Oct 12, 2011 10:46 am
by Blake Bruning
Adam, you could probably sell those, LOL
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Oct 12, 2011 5:35 pm
by iwantamorganreelbad1
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Oct 12, 2011 5:44 pm
by riku1914
_ wrote:I'm telling ya - the Irish and the mexicans are closely related somehow.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk...
I've got a lot of Irish in me...
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2012 4:07 am
by Indywanabe91
I just saw this video after randomly key-wording "bullwhip swing" on youtube. Adam if you were to make any of these stronger whips, I for one would love to own one. Not exactly for the accuracy but to have it for fun. Please let me know.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2012 2:52 pm
by Canuck Digger
riku1914 wrote:_ wrote:I'm telling ya - the Irish and the mexicans are closely related somehow.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk...
I've got a lot of Irish in me...
That's what she said...
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2016 1:22 pm
by adiemilio
Adam great video, I learned to do better cracks and variations with a whip about 8 years ago when I found some of your videos on youtube, but had not seen this one, it was recently tried on Mythbusters, but I haven't seen the full episode, here is a short Preview.
Indy's Whip And Leap Test | Mythbusters10
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mC_sGCCBby0" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
A. Savage in his video on how he made his Indy whip says you could not brake a 1/16 if an inch piece of Kangaroo hide because of how strong it is, made me think this stunt could be possible with a Morgan or Jacka whip without causing any damage to it, but Winrich being an expert of whips I guess has already tried that
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2016 5:11 pm
by adiemilio
Found the full episode.
https://youtu.be/NZDsrq_pfwI?list=PL6wk ... KeVApNOW6s" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2016 4:57 pm
by chenricy
already removed.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 1:12 pm
by adiemilio
chenricy wrote:
already removed.
Well it was plausible, A. Savage repeatedly swung from the whip, he made the whip himself with a DM Kangaroo hide, this is not his old first whip this is a new specifically made for the episode that actually looks more accurate; the whip was continuously slipping from the fake log they used that they hat to glue sandpaper to make it more abbrassive as real wood, which made them complete the swing with success. But I have no idea in what condition the whip was left, it seem fine all the way through, nothing was mentioned about it.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 1:22 pm
by Michaelson
I'll leave this right here for your enjoyment then:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiVmFiOecRg" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Regard! Michaelson
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 6:59 pm
by Tyrloch
Man, is that whip thick! Nice work for an amateur maker though! I just recently saw the Raiders Mythbusters episode, and I thoroughly enjoyed it! Anthony Delongis's cameo was a bonus! I always knew it was plausible to swing from a whip that was strong enough to hold one's body weight, bu it would more than likely ruin the taper. No disrespect intended to the grandfather of American bullwhips, rest his soul, but David Morgan's whips weren't tapered all that precisely to begin with. At least not like a highly technical Aussie type whip. The ease of cracking of a Morgan whip mostly came from the weight and the balance of it, so a bit of stretching from a swing wouldn't necessarily ruin the whip's ability to crack well, not unless it was destroyed in the process! Not to mention that going by the films, indy's whip was a tool: a useful but replaceable tool. So if swinging from it saved his skin, but decimated the whip, then he'd just grab a fresh one for his next adventure! I'm pretty sure he was paying far less for whips than what we have to! It's only at the current prices that we cringe at ruining a whip by swinging on it!!
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 2:45 am
by adiemilio
Tyrloch wrote: indy's whip was a tool: a useful but replaceable tool. So if swinging from it saved his skin, but decimated the whip, then he'd just grab a fresh one for his next adventure! I'm pretty sure he was paying far less for whips than what we have to! It's only at the current prices that we cringe at ruining a whip by swinging on it!!
I agree on that one, like a hammer or something an archaeologist would used, I guess the prices are so high right know that one cringes because of the demand, so replacing it easily those days wouldn't be so much of an issue. Just as Fedora's or Penman hat prices had to go up is because of the demand, but I really have no knowledge of the current prices during the 80's of Morgan whips so I really can't say.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Mon Mar 14, 2016 10:28 am
by chenricy
adiemilio wrote:Tyrloch wrote: indy's whip was a tool: a useful but replaceable tool. So if swinging from it saved his skin, but decimated the whip, then he'd just grab a fresh one for his next adventure! I'm pretty sure he was paying far less for whips than what we have to! It's only at the current prices that we cringe at ruining a whip by swinging on it!!
I agree on that one, like a hammer or something an archaeologist would used, I guess the prices are so high right know that one cringes because of the demand, so replacing it easily those days wouldn't be so much of an issue. Just as Fedora's or Penman hat prices had to go up is because of the demand, but I really have no knowledge of the current prices during the 80's of Morgan whips so I really can't say.
Seeing that he lost both his whip and his gun to Belloq right after the first scene it shows he can replace it ASAP shows he's used to losing them. Wonder why that is overlooked so much lol.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2016 3:15 am
by Satipo
chenricy wrote:Seeing that he lost both his whip and his gun to Belloq right after the first scene it shows he can replace it ASAP shows he's used to losing them. Wonder why that is overlooked so much lol.
Maybe Belloq mailed them back to him to further rub it in that he won that time.
Re: Swinging from a tree with a whip
Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2016 12:58 pm
by adiemilio
Satipo wrote:chenricy wrote:Seeing that he lost both his whip and his gun to Belloq right after the first scene it shows he can replace it ASAP shows he's used to losing them. Wonder why that is overlooked so much lol.
Maybe Belloq mailed them back to him to further rub it in that he won that time.
haha, he most probably trew them to the river. I also forgot, he replaced his shirt and shoulder bag after TOD.