Who makes the best bag strap?
Moderators: Mike, Cajunkraut, Tennessee Smith
Who makes the best bag strap?
I am not talking about buckle.
I have one from Magnoli (liked the color) but it's very soft. (Leave aside the buckle that isn't 100% accurate).
I don't know if a bag strap is supposed to be this. It reminds me the leather they use to make those timberland shoe laces.
Anyone has an NH bag strap or other and can talk about the qualities of the bag strap?
Should it be stiff, soft, or what?
Please share your thoughts.
I have one from Magnoli (liked the color) but it's very soft. (Leave aside the buckle that isn't 100% accurate).
I don't know if a bag strap is supposed to be this. It reminds me the leather they use to make those timberland shoe laces.
Anyone has an NH bag strap or other and can talk about the qualities of the bag strap?
Should it be stiff, soft, or what?
Please share your thoughts.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I currently only have a Todd's strap from about 2 years ago so I can't compare to anything else, but I've HEARD that Wade Egan's stuff is top notch. You might want to start there.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I second that! I got one last week and it rocks! Really SA, not too stiff, not too flexible, sturdy, just great!maboot38 wrote:... but I've HEARD that Wade Egan's stuff is top notch. You might want to start there.
Regards, Geert
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Geert, do you know how his strap compares to Todd's offering?gwyddion wrote:I second that! I got one last week and it rocks! Really SA, not too stiff, not too flexible, sturdy, just great!maboot38 wrote:... but I've HEARD that Wade Egan's stuff is top notch. You might want to start there.
Regards, Geert
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Who is Wade Egan and where can he be found
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
The straps and belts that Magnoli currently sells are made by Wade Egan
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Wade can be found in sunny California, but you can also find him here:
http://web.mac.com/wadeegan/Wadeventure/Bag_Straps.html
Oh, and he's also a member of this forum. His user name is....
...are you ready for it....
....Wade Egan.
http://web.mac.com/wadeegan/Wadeventure/Bag_Straps.html
Oh, and he's also a member of this forum. His user name is....
...are you ready for it....
....Wade Egan.
- Russian Raider
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2008 9:20 am
- Location: Russia
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I guess you figured out by now. Wade Egan is one of the best leathermen there is. His work is stunning!
- Indy Magnoli
- Staff Member
- Posts: 6974
- Joined: Mon Jul 08, 2002 4:00 am
- Location: Middle Earth, New Zealand
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
SEARCH!!!frogman wrote:Who is Wade Egan and where can he be found
But ya, Wade is definitely the guy to go to for straps and belts. Wade is the ONLY guy I buy my leather gear from.
Kyle
- Hollowpond
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3834
- Joined: Thu Apr 03, 2008 6:52 pm
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Wade, Wade, Wade, or Wade is the absolute best! Oh I almost forgot, you could also try Wade.
Travis
Travis
- JulianK
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 373
- Joined: Wed Jan 10, 2007 10:54 am
- Location: Gatineau (Ottawa Area), Canada
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
You can also try a saddlery (tack shop) ...horseback riding stuff. For CDN$19, I got a custom made strap out of English bridle leather complete with Chicago screws. The only thing missing was the buckle....which you already have. My only complaint is that it'll take years to distress this thing! It went to S. America for 5 weeks with me and still looks brand #$%$# new!
- Texan Scott
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 5838
- Joined: Sat Jun 21, 2008 8:55 am
- Location: A felt body at rest tends to stay at rest. Sieze the day!
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
WPG also makes the thinner, dark brown, softer strap and Todd sells the thicker strap, If budget is an issue.
-
- Field Surveyor
- Posts: 80
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2008 2:11 pm
- Location: A Canuck in the UK
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Makes sense, I saw Magnoli's on the website and swore it was Wade's so that makes sense ...
mine is going to ordered soon, streets of cario style, or crusade .... which to do, how to decide!
e
mine is going to ordered soon, streets of cario style, or crusade .... which to do, how to decide!
e
-
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1705
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2008 11:47 am
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I hear an echo, but I'm adding to it... Wade's stuff is incredible. Hand CRAFTED not made.. crafted. Anyone with some leather working tools can make a strap.. an artist crafts something out of leather.
Randy
Randy
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I was wondering if someone would be willing to write a little essay or something describing what makes one strip of leather better than another. I'm not joking around, I would really like to know. I've heard great things about Wade's products, but what is it that makes Wades leather strap head over heels better than Todd's or some other leather strap? I'd love to hear descriptions of texture, durability, feel, response, etc.
-
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1705
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2008 11:47 am
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Well, my Todd's strap is nice for $20 or whatever it costs, but feels "stamped out" I had to do quite a bit of distressing and an alcohol treatment before it looked old. For a little more.. okay, probably close to twice the money, I had a piece that felt like time was taken to craft it, and was instantly aged. The buckle is much nicer, and now he has that more SA version, too. It boils down to the same argument that takes place in the fedora section.. hand crafted vs. machine made/partially handmade. While neither is 100% right or wrong, from a certain point of view, I must say in this case, handcrafted looks and feels nicer out of the package.
But, if you're on a budget, or simply up for a little DIY distressing, the Todd's is a great choice. I'd buy another in a heart beat, and probably will be in the near future. Hope that helped a little.
Randy
::EDIT::
This was in no way meant to knock Todd's products! I love my strap after a little modification. I say buy what you can afford, I'd never tell someone who could only spend in the Todd's price range to get something more expensive!
But, if you're on a budget, or simply up for a little DIY distressing, the Todd's is a great choice. I'd buy another in a heart beat, and probably will be in the near future. Hope that helped a little.
Randy
::EDIT::
This was in no way meant to knock Todd's products! I love my strap after a little modification. I say buy what you can afford, I'd never tell someone who could only spend in the Todd's price range to get something more expensive!
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
All I can say is that I hand pick the best hides and personally cut the strap from the nicest of leathers. Then I skive the strap to just the right thickness and hand bevel (hand groove for Raiders) the edges before applying the dye and edge treatment. I have a system for applying the dye and finish which helps to give the straps the best look for the Indy application. Then I work each strap over with my hands for a minute before applying the final 'top coat' to keep the dye from coming out. Finally a 'secret sauce' is applied to help soften and age the leather before the buckle and hardware are attached. Then it's off to the races.
No machines are used in the making of the straps and belts. They are (with the exception of the hardware) totally hand crafted from start to finish. People sometimes argue that the machine cut and drum dyed straps have more even color, but in my opinion they lack character. Also, machined grooved strap (Raiders) leave a really deep groove that will most likely never wear totally out like we've seen on screen. Of course, the character can be added later and for some is part of the fun of owning a piece of leather gear. Leather is something that just looks better the more it is used and worked with (IMO). So I personally don't think it possible for a machine to put the right character into a piece as can be done when making something by hand. Grain, thickness, finish, they all play a major part. Think in terms of furniture. Hand made oak furniture will look better than Ikea oak furniture any day of the week, and last a lot longer. The process is not too dissimilar.
Again, it simply comes down to personal preference, which is why we offer Standard and Deluxe style straps. Options are always nice.
W.E.
No machines are used in the making of the straps and belts. They are (with the exception of the hardware) totally hand crafted from start to finish. People sometimes argue that the machine cut and drum dyed straps have more even color, but in my opinion they lack character. Also, machined grooved strap (Raiders) leave a really deep groove that will most likely never wear totally out like we've seen on screen. Of course, the character can be added later and for some is part of the fun of owning a piece of leather gear. Leather is something that just looks better the more it is used and worked with (IMO). So I personally don't think it possible for a machine to put the right character into a piece as can be done when making something by hand. Grain, thickness, finish, they all play a major part. Think in terms of furniture. Hand made oak furniture will look better than Ikea oak furniture any day of the week, and last a lot longer. The process is not too dissimilar.
Again, it simply comes down to personal preference, which is why we offer Standard and Deluxe style straps. Options are always nice.
W.E.
- lantzn
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1622
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 4:29 pm
- Location: Washington State
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
True, and the bags that Wade sells are made by Magnoli, so it's a matched made in Indy Heaven.djd wrote:The straps and belts that Magnoli currently sells are made by Wade Egan
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
maboot how is your two year old Todd's strap made? I've heard the older ones are two thin pieces of leather glued together with shorter lengths of leather pieced together for length. The current Todd's straps are one piece of solid leather.
- generalFROSTY
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 774
- Joined: Mon Nov 23, 2009 11:58 pm
- Location: Lancaster, PA
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
So Wade makes the best strap on the market - how does his bag compare? Is his bag considered THE best?? That's what I am after - only the best cuz I want to get it right the first time.
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
As said above, Wade sells Magnoli bags. I think he also occasionally sells original bags.
- generalFROSTY
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 774
- Joined: Mon Nov 23, 2009 11:58 pm
- Location: Lancaster, PA
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
So that's a 'yes' on the Magnoli/wade bag being THE best?RCSignals wrote:As said above, Wade sells Magnoli bags. I think he also occasionally sells original bags.
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I don't know. I've only seen the Magnoli in photos, and it looks to be a very good reproduction. I doubt you'd go wrong with one, and I doubt any one looking at you with it would know it's not an original.generalFROSTY wrote:So that's a 'yes' on the Magnoli/wade bag being THE best?RCSignals wrote:As said above, Wade sells Magnoli bags. I think he also occasionally sells original bags.
The current Todd's is also a very good reproduction, I have one of those.
- lantzn
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1622
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 4:29 pm
- Location: Washington State
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I've searched and researched and have decided myself to go with the Magnoli bag/Wade deluxe strap on Wade's site. I too want to get it right the first time and feel I've made the right choice.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
The Magnoli bag is a lovely bag- very well put together. I would say that the colour is slightly off though. Not quite green enough compared to the original bags.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
You might consider getting one of Todd's bags if you want SA color.
(but this is coming from the guy who loves his magnoli bag, really you can't go wring either way.)
(but this is coming from the guy who loves his magnoli bag, really you can't go wring either way.)
Last edited by Photoss on Wed Dec 02, 2009 2:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Agreed! Funnily enough, the Magnoli bag looks greener when you photograph it so I guess it could be screen accurate in a sense...
- lantzn
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1622
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 4:29 pm
- Location: Washington State
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Figures, right after I decide on the Wade CS strap, this thread is renewed and these 7/8" straps/buckles become available.
I think I'm going to order one.
viewtopic.php?f=16&t=43469
I think I'm going to order one.
viewtopic.php?f=16&t=43469
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Just so you know, I can easily make a 7/8" strap with the SA roller buckle. Not a problem.
W.E.
W.E.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Why does the best always has to be the most expensive?
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Because quality comes at a pricefrogman wrote:Why does the best always has to be the most expensive?
Regards, Geert
- Risu
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 723
- Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2007 9:19 am
- Location: Sprandy of Little Chair
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I used to have a Magnoli bag, it was very nice in terms of materials. My eyes don't pick up variances in green very well, but to me his bag is 100% light khaki, not green at all. that was a deal breaker for me, so I got an original. Wade also sells those.
- lantzn
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1622
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 4:29 pm
- Location: Washington State
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I don't see originals on Wade's site. What is the cost and do they have the little loop on the side?Risu wrote:I used to have a Magnoli bag, it was very nice in terms of materials. My eyes don't pick up variances in green very well, but to me his bag is 100% light khaki, not green at all. that was a deal breaker for me, so I got an original. Wade also sells those.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
It doesn't. Sometimes people equate quality with expense. Sometimes, the item actually IS better and sometimes it's just more expensive. There's a lot of nice gear out there for less money. It just doesn't get the fanfare the more expensive stuff does. Most of the bag straps mentioned are really good. Whoever said "buy what you can afford" hit the nail right on the head.frogman wrote:Why does the best always has to be the most expensive?
Regards, Dr. J
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
The best doesn't have to be the most expensive, but quality normally has a higher price.
If the best was always related to most expensive, Belstaff's CS jacket would be number one on everyone's list.
If the best was always related to most expensive, Belstaff's CS jacket would be number one on everyone's list.
- Risu
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 723
- Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2007 9:19 am
- Location: Sprandy of Little Chair
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Not sure what you mean by the loop, but if it's on the original bags there's no reason we'd remove it. PM Wade if you're interested in one, he can tell you if there are any in stock.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
There's a little loop on the side of a MKVII with string on it.The original bags were disigned to be worn on the chest with the gas mask inside it so it would reach to your face. My original MK VII has this loop and had the string with it, which I got from Soldier of Fortune.Risu wrote:Not sure what you mean by the loop, but if it's on the original bags there's no reason we'd remove it. PM Wade if you're interested in one, he can tell you if there are any in stock.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
All the decent repros I've seen have the loop (although it's much shorter on some than others)- only the original ones I've had have had the string as well (but it is just string ).
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
My original bags are the same as WPG bags and the same price. I don't sell them for a profit. I just keep a few in the shop for reference and photos etc., and when a customer is in a pinch I sell them for what I pay for them. It's a convenience thing not an investment. I like to be prepared for whatever. WPG still has plenty of good ones.
I'm just making this up as I go.
W.E.
I'm just making this up as I go.
W.E.
- lantzn
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1622
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 4:29 pm
- Location: Washington State
- Contact:
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
One of the others posted they had dry rot issues with a WPG bag. Have you had any of these issues?Wade Egan wrote:My original bags are the same as WPG bags and the same price. I don't sell them for a profit. I just keep a few in the shop for reference and photos etc., and when a customer is in a pinch I sell them for what I pay for them. It's a convenience thing not an investment. I like to be prepared for whatever. WPG still has plenty of good ones.
I'm just making this up as I go.
W.E.
- generalFROSTY
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 774
- Joined: Mon Nov 23, 2009 11:58 pm
- Location: Lancaster, PA
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I am at odds as to which bag to go with - WPG or Todds. Magnoli's is not the right color and that's enough for me to stay away despite Magnoli's awesome quality.
With the WPG you have a real vintage bag which, IMO, you don't get better than that - however it's age could effect it's structural integrity.
On the other hand, Todds bag looks just as good, is newer, but I have read many reports of Todds items not being sewn together all that well (hence the low cost items).
I would like to see some side-by-side comparisons of these items.
With the WPG you have a real vintage bag which, IMO, you don't get better than that - however it's age could effect it's structural integrity.
On the other hand, Todds bag looks just as good, is newer, but I have read many reports of Todds items not being sewn together all that well (hence the low cost items).
I would like to see some side-by-side comparisons of these items.
- rover smith
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 324
- Joined: Wed Nov 26, 2008 6:06 am
- Location: Glasgow
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Theres always ebay for an unissued original, there always seem to be a few of these kicking around. If you're patient you can get pretty good ones.I am at odds as to which bag to go with - WPG or Todds. Magnoli's is not the right color and that's enough for me to stay away despite Magnoli's awesome quality.
With the WPG you have a real vintage bag which, IMO, you don't get better than that - however it's age could effect it's structural integrity.
On the other hand, Todds bag looks just as good, is newer, but I have read many reports of Todds items not being sewn together all that well (hence the low cost items).
I would like to see some side-by-side comparisons of these items.
- Indiana Bugs
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 829
- Joined: Sat Nov 07, 2009 4:24 pm
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
I have one of the WPG new bags, and a strap from them, as well. I think both are made very well, so thats something to consider.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
As I've posted elsewhere before, I've had two perfect (unused and unmarked) originals fail. I may have just been unlucky but I think if you're actually going to use the bag I'd go for a good repro over an original. Just my feeling on it nowgeneralFROSTY wrote:I am at odds as to which bag to go with - WPG or Todds. Magnoli's is not the right color and that's enough for me to stay away despite Magnoli's awesome quality.
With the WPG you have a real vintage bag which, IMO, you don't get better than that - however it's age could effect it's structural integrity.
On the other hand, Todds bag looks just as good, is newer, but I have read many reports of Todds items not being sewn together all that well (hence the low cost items).
I would like to see some side-by-side comparisons of these items.
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
the only report I've read of a current Todd's bag stitch failure was from someone who admitted he had caused it when distressing the bag and sanding over the thread too much.generalFROSTY wrote:.........
On the other hand, Todds bag looks just as good, is newer, but I have read many reports of Todds items not being sewn together all that well (hence the low cost items).
...........
There should be photos of most of the various bags throughout this forum.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
lantzn wrote:One of the others posted they had dry rot issues with a WPG bag. Have you had any of these issues?Wade Egan wrote:My original bags are the same as WPG bags and the same price. I don't sell them for a profit. I just keep a few in the shop for reference and photos etc., and when a customer is in a pinch I sell them for what I pay for them. It's a convenience thing not an investment. I like to be prepared for whatever. WPG still has plenty of good ones.
I'm just making this up as I go.
W.E.
I have had dry rot on the the webbing ring attachments, but I just replace it with new webbing myself. Other than that, the bags have been good and only a little stinky from years of storage. I'm pretty sure we're getting down to the wire with the original MK VIIs. I'm not sure how much longer WPG and other will be able to stock the bags as supplies are dwindling.
I would just email WPG and ask for the best looking bag possible and you will probably get a nice one.
W.E.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
That's exactly where my bags failed Wade. They looked fine right up to the point that the webbing just suddenly gave out!
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
In an attempt to rectify this issue I'm going to throw my Magnoli in the washing machine with some olive green fabric dye and see if I end up with a better colour....Risu wrote:I used to have a Magnoli bag, it was very nice in terms of materials. My eyes don't pick up variances in green very well, but to me his bag is 100% light khaki, not green at all. that was a deal breaker for me, so I got an original. Wade also sells those.
Re: Who makes the best bag strap?
Yep, the webbing is the first thing to go. As the original bags are getting more scarce as time goes by, I would pick up some new ones and simply replace the webbing with a newer and stronger webbing in a matched color. This will give the OG MKVii new life and longevity.
I've fixed about 5 bags this way. I also noticed that on my last order of WPG bags that the webbing was new. Most likely replaced before they sold them.
W.E.
I've fixed about 5 bags this way. I also noticed that on my last order of WPG bags that the webbing was new. Most likely replaced before they sold them.
W.E.