Page 1 of 1
Morgan today vs Morgan yesteryears
Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2005 9:15 am
by kriegfeld jr
How different is the DM whip today from the ones used in Raiders? When I talked to Morgan, he said that the whips back then were made of calfskin because of an embargo on roo. Other then that, what are the visual differences?
Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2005 9:20 am
by VP
Sergei wrote:More specifically he does not like putting the turks head knot on the end of the handle at 8 inches - like in Raiders. At 8 inches, that knot is right over the end of the 8 inch nail spike. That's were there is a lot of force and knots have failed right over the spike. As an engineer, placement of that knot at 8 inches would be an integrity issue with him - BIG TIME. This is because he knows the failure rate.
Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2005 9:31 am
by kriegfeld jr
I was also wondering if the actual knot has changed. In some of the Raider pictures...it looks more like a cone. Now they look more like a ball?
Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2005 12:59 pm
by Sergei
This has been dscussed a lot of times. Many, many postings exist in the whip section. Just do a search. I have even posted measurements and diagrams. It's more than just knot placement and shape of knots.
-Sergei
My opinion of Morgan vs Strain
Posted: Tue Mar 22, 2005 1:10 am
by kriegfeld jr
I've owned some nice whips. I used to have two joe strains (10' & 12'), and I currently own a DM 10'. My opinion is that joe strain makes a tighter braid with a fast a fluid action. DMs braid is not as tight but with a much wider cut of leather. DM looks more like an Indy whip but the joe strain feels a bit more solid. I've kept my DM because it functions well and has the added bonus of looking the part.
Re: My opinion of Morgan vs Strain
Posted: Tue Mar 22, 2005 2:07 am
by Sergei
kriegfeld jr wrote:I've owned some nice whips. I used to have two joe strains (10' & 12'), and I currently own a DM 10'. My opinion is that joe strain makes a tighter braid with a fast a fluid action. DMs braid is not as tight but with a much wider cut of leather. DM looks more like an Indy whip but the joe strain feels a bit more solid. I've kept my DM because it functions well and has the added bonus of looking the part.
That's a good synopsis between a Strain and a Morgan.