The most SA wested raiders jacket since the film!
Moderators: Indiana Jeff, Mike, Indydawg
- JimL
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 777
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 11:37 pm
- Location: CT, Long Island, NY
- Contact:
It took quite a while for my wested Horse to show any signs of absorbing water at all. It just beads up and rolls off...
Horse is typically cut thicker (even at Wested) so that accounts for the difference in "drape". If the Horse was thinned to Goat thickness, it would be quite similar. But then, why do it? Horse will offer more protection from abrasion due to the added thickness, and the Wested Horse breaks in VERY quickly I am learning...
I do like Goat, and for the look/strength ratio, that is definately the way to go for an Indy jacket!
Horse is typically cut thicker (even at Wested) so that accounts for the difference in "drape". If the Horse was thinned to Goat thickness, it would be quite similar. But then, why do it? Horse will offer more protection from abrasion due to the added thickness, and the Wested Horse breaks in VERY quickly I am learning...
I do like Goat, and for the look/strength ratio, that is definately the way to go for an Indy jacket!
-
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 229
- Joined: Mon Sep 24, 2007 8:25 pm
- Location: Right in the middle
- Contact:
Well, a thicker hide might protect you from breaking bones. Goatskin is actually more abrasion resistant than horsehide as far as the hide itself. The only thing that can surpass goatskin on the strength to weight ratio is kangaroo hide. A good hide for motorcycles is actually deerskin from what I understand. It has a natural sponginess to the hide that is really great in a fall.J!m wrote:It took quite a while for my wested Horse to show any signs of absorbing water at all. It just beads up and rolls off...
Horse is typically cut thicker (even at Wested) so that accounts for the difference in "drape". If the Horse was thinned to Goat thickness, it would be quite similar. But then, why do it? Horse will offer more protection from abrasion due to the added thickness, and the Wested Horse breaks in VERY quickly I am learning...
I do like Goat, and for the look/strength ratio, that is definately the way to go for an Indy jacket!
I don't profess to be an expert on motorcycle clothing; I’m only stating what I have heard. Here’s an article.
http://ezinearticles.com/?Motorcycle-Pr ... !&id=13040
http://ezinearticles.com/?Motorcycle-Pr ... !&id=13040
I have finally come to the conclusion that the Indy jacket, as much as I tried to make it work, isn't designed well for motorcycling. I know others use it, but for me, getting slapped by the collar, and having my back exposed when it rides up just don't work. I started theorizing last week that the ToD jacket might do better than a Raiders or CS, but remind myself just to let it go.knibs7 wrote:I'm not trying to sound like a wise guy here, but I was just wondering... can a thicker hide really keep you from breaking bones?
Nibs
Here's what I did wearing my G&B goat AND an armoured Belstaff cordura jacket OVER that. (The right is a Bennet's fracture; hard to see, but the thumb joint is broken by the hand; in any case, both arms were cast, which I'll tell you is pretty inconvenient.)
- Indiana G
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3918
- Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 12:55 pm
- Location: in the Temple of Insanity
leather does not stop bones from breaking but will protect from abrasion and some penetrations........and perhaps cushioin to a miniscule degree on impact. bones break because that part of your body wasn't suppose to go that way.......to protect against that, you will require support and reinforcement, which leather does not give you unless the leather has supports and reinforcements as well. some racing leathers has spinal reinforcements built in. your everyday jackets whether it be wested, g&b, us wings, todds, TN, will fair poorly against any force that is strong enough to break bones.
btw baldwn.......thank's for making me gag.........
btw baldwn.......thank's for making me gag.........
-
- Laboratory Technician
- Posts: 191
- Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 5:24 pm
- Location: Aberdeen, UK
6.1'Nebraska Brad wrote:Holt that is simply an amazing jacket! I may have missed it in this long thread but could you provide your height, weight, shoulder and chest size? This jacket may sway me from a TN1 if I could get the specs nailed down like yours.
-Nebraska
200 pounds
46'' chest
Last edited by Holt on Sun Jan 11, 2009 7:13 am, edited 1 time in total.
It's an old thing, completely healed, although the plate in my arm sometimes bugs me. No biggie, when the alternatives could be much worse!IndyGeek78 wrote:oooohhhhhhhhhh Thats nasty. Sorry to hear about your injuries man. One question tho and Please take this as it's meant (very light hearted) how's the jacket?
The jacket was perfect of course! There was a scuff mark and small tear on the shoulder seam of the Belstaff, but nothing on the Indy. Tore through seventeen layers of kevlar on my knee though. Hate to think how it'd look without the kevlar
- RaiderZee
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 417
- Joined: Wed Nov 12, 2008 12:51 am
- Location: South Carolina: "two weeks from everywhere"
Fantastic jacket, Holt! That's the jacket I've wanted since, well, 1981. One question about hides again. I love the look of the goat, and I know it's tough. However, I live in SC. Doesn't get much below 25 F at night in winter, and of course we hit 100+ a bunch in the summer. Any idea how goat holds heat compared to lamb/horse/etc.?
Thanks,
RaiderZee
Thanks,
RaiderZee
- JimL
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 777
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 11:37 pm
- Location: CT, Long Island, NY
- Contact:
Best to stick with Lamb in that heat. Themore dense and durable the leather, the less able to pass vapor, and then it gets 'wet' and 'clammy' inside, which is not comfortable in 100+ heat. If humidity is very low (ala Arizona) this is much less of a problem, unless you sweat more than normal...RaiderZee wrote:Fantastic jacket, Holt! That's the jacket I've wanted since, well, 1981. One question about hides again. I love the look of the goat, and I know it's tough. However, I live in SC. Doesn't get much below 25 F at night in winter, and of course we hit 100+ a bunch in the summer. Any idea how goat holds heat compared to lamb/horse/etc.?
Thanks,
RaiderZee
- Rom Hunter
- Laboratory Technician
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Thu Feb 14, 2008 2:24 pm
- Mitch LaRue
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3147
- Joined: Tue Jul 01, 2008 2:41 pm
- Location: Nova Scotia, Canada
Probably not as I asked for Holt's yolk specs and Marc Kittner's pocket specs on my last Raiders custom.WhipDude wrote:I think that's a great idea. Seems to be the general consensus that everybody thinks this is perfect.
I also wonder if Peter would go nuts if I requested holt specs...
And I've been tossing this around for a while now. I really love my Wested HH but Holt's collar looks so good to me. If I could get that collar on my jacket, it would be perfect (at least for me). This is probably a dunce question, but is it just the collar that's bigger or did the surrounding leather have to be modified for the bigger collar as well. If it's just the collar, I would seriously consider sending my Wested back to have alterations on the collar over the summer (when I wouldn't miss it as much )
- Indiana G
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3918
- Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 12:55 pm
- Location: in the Temple of Insanity
the collar length/storm flap length is longer as proportioned to the 2 front panels. in order to accomodate that, the front panel templates need to be revised (ie- more leather removed so the opening when fully zipped up is larger). now if you've made up all the patterns for all the sizes already....this is quite difficult to change globally.crismans wrote:Probably not as I asked for Holt's yolk specs and Marc Kittner's pocket specs on my last Raiders custom.WhipDude wrote:I think that's a great idea. Seems to be the general consensus that everybody thinks this is perfect.
I also wonder if Peter would go nuts if I requested holt specs...
And I've been tossing this around for a while now. I really love my Wested HH but Holt's collar looks so good to me. If I could get that collar on my jacket, it would be perfect (at least for me). This is probably a dunce question, but is it just the collar that's bigger or did the surrounding leather have to be modified for the bigger collar as well. If it's just the collar, I would seriously consider sending my Wested back to have alterations on the collar over the summer (when I wouldn't miss it as much )
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
I don't think so. I don't think the huge collar is anything but perception from certain scenes. In other words if there was an original pattern being used, I doubt it would have such a collar.Indiana G wrote:.....forgot to mention....as the longer collar sits lower on the front panels now, the zipper length will also need to be shortened.....alot of stuff goes on for an authentic collar......but isn't this something that should of been in the pattern all along? ;-)
TN's jacket certainly didn't result in such a collar, and it would have if it was a reality on the jacket.
- Indiana G
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3918
- Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 12:55 pm
- Location: in the Temple of Insanity
i do not think that what TN had was indeed the hero jacket.....which was peter's prototype made for deb nadoolman......at least not the one in the raven bar, nor the temple scenes........nor the WOS scenes for that matter......RCSignals wrote:I don't think so. I don't think the huge collar is anything but perception from certain scenes. In other words if there was an original pattern being used, I doubt it would have such a collar.Indiana G wrote:.....forgot to mention....as the longer collar sits lower on the front panels now, the zipper length will also need to be shortened.....alot of stuff goes on for an authentic collar......but isn't this something that should of been in the pattern all along? ;-)
TN's jacket certainly didn't result in such a collar, and it would have if it was a reality on the jacket.
your exactly right in that screen grabs don't tell the entire story.....they do however, tell over 50% of the story ;-)
since there are a bajillion wested's, and numerous todd's jackets floating around......can anyone post proof that the screen collar length was per today's standard offering.....recreating angle of shot and what have you? i can't even do it with my shrunken lamb TN.....but i'm a 44 jacket size and supposedly ford was a 40 back then. can anyone show that the collar was as per today's design? {ps - a size 38 person wearing a size 46 jacket doesn't count}
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
I'm beginning to believe what TN had was in fact a HF worn hero jacket, and may well have been that 'protoype'Indiana G wrote:i do not think that what TN had was indeed the hero jacket.....which was peter's prototype made for deb nadoolman......at least not the one in the raven bar, nor the temple scenes........nor the WOS scenes for that matter......RCSignals wrote:I don't think so. I don't think the huge collar is anything but perception from certain scenes. In other words if there was an original pattern being used, I doubt it would have such a collar.Indiana G wrote:.....forgot to mention....as the longer collar sits lower on the front panels now, the zipper length will also need to be shortened.....alot of stuff goes on for an authentic collar......but isn't this something that should of been in the pattern all along? ;-)
TN's jacket certainly didn't result in such a collar, and it would have if it was a reality on the jacket.
your exactly right in that screen grabs don't tell the entire story.....they do however, tell over 50% of the story ;-)
since there are a bajillion wested's, and numerous todd's jackets floating around......can anyone post proof that the screen collar length was per today's standard offering.....recreating angle of shot and what have you? i can't even do it with my shrunken lamb TN.....but i'm a 44 jacket size and supposedly ford was a 40 back then. can anyone show that the collar was as per today's design? {ps - a size 38 person wearing a size 46 jacket doesn't count}
that said I don't think HF wore the same jacket throughout Raiders, and that's supported from the movie itself and anecdotal evidence.
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
perspective, perception, is still off there.Indiana G wrote:
standard wested. perception of length can be elusive when viewing head on......not so much on a profile view.
If you lighten the photo, the collar itself is not that wide, and it appears the jacket is calling off his shoulder slightly, as well as to his front, toward the camera view, so it may not be as large around the neck either. It's hard to believe that a jacket would be made with a 20" or so collar when it isn't necessary.
We do know that the 'second batch' of jackets apparently were all quite different from one another.
just for the fun of it.
take a look here,I lightend the photo of Ford up a bit.all though the collar is not 100% SA,it is still very close and good enough for me.and it is is the most SA collar knocked out of wested since the flick. IMO
my quest about a super accurate raiders wested is over.to give you the truth,I have become a bit tired of this wole SA thing.Im tired of chasing rabbits.but that doesnt mean that I wont get another wested jacket again.I know that I will,Peter has something awesome coming in soon,but I am sworn to secrecy,so please dont ask! but now I am in the mood for a temple of doom jacket, and not have to worrie about getting the details right,that will be a new thing for me,so we will see how I react to it ;-)
take a look here,I lightend the photo of Ford up a bit.all though the collar is not 100% SA,it is still very close and good enough for me.and it is is the most SA collar knocked out of wested since the flick. IMO
my quest about a super accurate raiders wested is over.to give you the truth,I have become a bit tired of this wole SA thing.Im tired of chasing rabbits.but that doesnt mean that I wont get another wested jacket again.I know that I will,Peter has something awesome coming in soon,but I am sworn to secrecy,so please dont ask! but now I am in the mood for a temple of doom jacket, and not have to worrie about getting the details right,that will be a new thing for me,so we will see how I react to it ;-)
- Don't Call Me Junior!
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Fri Dec 01, 2006 2:25 pm
- Location: United States (CT)
Holt, I'm with you on this 100%. As many people have said, Harrison Ford could've come right off the set of Raiders and given you the jacket right off of his back. There would still be people nitpicking THAT jacket over screen accuracy.Indiana Holt wrote:my quest about a super accurate raiders wested is over.to give you the truth,I have become a bit tired of this wole SA thing.Im tired of chasing rabbits.but that doesnt mean that I wont get another wested jacket again.
The ONLY thing that matters in the end is whether or not you love the jacket you received. Does it fit you? Do you like the way it looks on you and off? Do you like the leather? Amen, brother!
I, and apparently a few others, think that your latest Wested is one of the best Raiders jackets I've ever seen from Wested. But if you didn't like it what would any of that matter? (I'm glad your really do love it though!)
Having said that: Hey, I can't wait to see your next jacket, Holt!
- Raider Of The Lost Ark
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 314
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 3:53 am
I also know what Peter is planning and your right, it should be very nice! However the look of your jacket is what my mind thinks the original jacket looked like. On that basis, it rocks!Indiana Holt wrote:just for the fun of it.
take a look here,I lightend the photo of Ford up a bit.all though the collar is not 100% SA,it is still very close and good enough for me.and it is is the most SA collar knocked out of wested since the flick. IMO
my quest about a super accurate raiders wested is over.to give you the truth,I have become a bit tired of this wole SA thing.Im tired of chasing rabbits.but that doesnt mean that I wont get another wested jacket again.I know that I will,Peter has something awesome coming in soon,but I am sworn to secrecy,so please dont ask! but now I am in the mood for a temple of doom jacket, and not have to worrie about getting the details right,that will be a new thing for me,so we will see how I react to it ;-
)
-
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3665
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:32 pm
- Location: Twin Galaxies
Don't get me wrong Holt. I think your jacket is great, and you have a good eye for these things. i just don't think the jacket in that picture has a collar 'too large' for Ford's neck.Indiana Holt wrote:just for the fun of it.
take a look here,I lightend the photo of Ford up a bit.all though the collar is not 100% SA,it is still very close and good enough for me.and it is is the most SA collar knocked out of wested since the flick. IMO
my quest about a super accurate raiders wested is over.to give you the truth,I have become a bit tired of this wole SA thing.Im tired of chasing rabbits.but that doesnt mean that I wont get another wested jacket again.I know that I will,Peter has something awesome coming in soon,but I am sworn to secrecy,so please dont ask! but now I am in the mood for a temple of doom jacket, and not have to worrie about getting the details right,that will be a new thing for me,so we will see how I react to it ;-)
I can't wait to hear what you think of your ToD jacket.