Going to order my Indy jacket, any last minute comments?
Moderators: Indiana Jeff, Mike, Indydawg
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Going to order my Indy jacket, any last minute comments?
Ok so within a week I believe, I'm going to order my first Indiana Jones inspired jacket. Does anyone have any last minute comments, tips, advice, opinions and/or reviews etc?
As some of you probably know I've decided not to go the SA route for a few reasons. 1) I want this as an actual coat that I can wear with featuers I want in any coat and not just for a costume piece 2) If it just looks like Indy's and people will say hey that's Indy's jacket, that's great 3) I don't weigh what I'll weigh in a year's time. I'll weigh less so when that time comes I can send in real measurements for a nice SA jacket.
http://uswings.com/sigseries.asp#SSGoatA2-2000
Again, I know it isn't SA and Indy's didn't have elastic cuffs/waistband but those are what I really want. Also the side pockets are seen here.. but that's good imo.
I mean really it's what Indy's jacket was based off of (partly), has front cargo pockets that really match. It's the same dark color etc.. I think it looks good.
As some of you probably know I've decided not to go the SA route for a few reasons. 1) I want this as an actual coat that I can wear with featuers I want in any coat and not just for a costume piece 2) If it just looks like Indy's and people will say hey that's Indy's jacket, that's great 3) I don't weigh what I'll weigh in a year's time. I'll weigh less so when that time comes I can send in real measurements for a nice SA jacket.
http://uswings.com/sigseries.asp#SSGoatA2-2000
Again, I know it isn't SA and Indy's didn't have elastic cuffs/waistband but those are what I really want. Also the side pockets are seen here.. but that's good imo.
I mean really it's what Indy's jacket was based off of (partly), has front cargo pockets that really match. It's the same dark color etc.. I think it looks good.
Last edited by blueoakleyz on Sun Oct 26, 2008 6:06 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 770
- Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 10:25 am
- Location: Australia
-
- Field Surveyor
- Posts: 64
- Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2008 12:11 pm
- Location: Pennsylvania
- scot2525
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 760
- Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 9:56 pm
- Location: Northeast of Indy
Re: Going to order my Indy jacket, any last minute comments?
The A2 USwings jacket is a very nice jacket and I hope you wear it in good health. But please refrain from calling it an Indy jacket, it may be the style the jacket was based on but it is far from the actual jacket.blueoakleyz wrote:Ok so within a week I believe, I'm going to order my first Indiana Jones inspired jacket. Does anyone have any last minute comments, tips, advice, opinions and/or reviews etc?
As some of you probably know I've decided not to go the SA route for a few reasons. 1) I want this as an actual coat that I can wear with featuers I want in any coat and not just for a costume piece 2) If it just looks like Indy's and people will say hey that's Indy's jacket, that's great 3) I don't weigh what I'll weigh in a year's time. I'll weigh less so when that time comes I can send in real measurements for a nice SA jacket.
http://uswings.com/sigseries.asp#SSGoatA2-2000
Again, I know it isn't SA and Indy's didn't have elastic cuffs/waistband but those are what I really want. Also the side pockets are seen here.. but that's good imo.
I mean really it's what Indy's jacket was based off of (partly), has front cargo pockets that really match. It's the same dark color etc.. I think it looks good.
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Re: Going to order my Indy jacket, any last minute comments?
scot2525 wrote:The A2 USwings jacket is a very nice jacket and I hope you wear it in good health. But please refrain from calling it an Indy jacket, it may be the style the jacket was based on but it is far from the actual jacket.blueoakleyz wrote:Ok so within a week I believe, I'm going to order my first Indiana Jones inspired jacket. Does anyone have any last minute comments, tips, advice, opinions and/or reviews etc?
As some of you probably know I've decided not to go the SA route for a few reasons. 1) I want this as an actual coat that I can wear with featuers I want in any coat and not just for a costume piece 2) If it just looks like Indy's and people will say hey that's Indy's jacket, that's great 3) I don't weigh what I'll weigh in a year's time. I'll weigh less so when that time comes I can send in real measurements for a nice SA jacket.
http://uswings.com/sigseries.asp#SSGoatA2-2000
Again, I know it isn't SA and Indy's didn't have elastic cuffs/waistband but those are what I really want. Also the side pockets are seen here.. but that's good imo.
I mean really it's what Indy's jacket was based off of (partly), has front cargo pockets that really match. It's the same dark color etc.. I think it looks good.
I'm definitely going to call it my/an Indy jacket. It might not be the most SA but it's definitely close. Dark brown, leather, cargo pockets. Everyone will recognize it as one. It's akin to someone going into a leather store and picking out a brown leather jacket and calling it his Indy jacket even if it's even less SA.
Re: Going to order my Indy jacket, any last minute comments?
Call your jacket you want - Fred, Harry or Wilber... for all I care. We can't stop you. But to some of us here, an A2 has almost nothing to do with Indiana Jones. It is a well known flying jacket and there are many places you can duiscuss them on line.blueoakleyz wrote:scot2525 wrote:The A2 USwings jacket is a very nice jacket and I hope you wear it in good health. But please refrain from calling it an Indy jacket, it may be the style the jacket was based on but it is far from the actual jacket.blueoakleyz wrote:Ok so within a week I believe, I'm going to order my first Indiana Jones inspired jacket. Does anyone have any last minute comments, tips, advice, opinions and/or reviews etc?
As some of you probably know I've decided not to go the SA route for a few reasons. 1) I want this as an actual coat that I can wear with featuers I want in any coat and not just for a costume piece 2) If it just looks like Indy's and people will say hey that's Indy's jacket, that's great 3) I don't weigh what I'll weigh in a year's time. I'll weigh less so when that time comes I can send in real measurements for a nice SA jacket.
http://uswings.com/sigseries.asp#SSGoatA2-2000
Again, I know it isn't SA and Indy's didn't have elastic cuffs/waistband but those are what I really want. Also the side pockets are seen here.. but that's good imo.
I mean really it's what Indy's jacket was based off of (partly), has front cargo pockets that really match. It's the same dark color etc.. I think it looks good.
I'm definitely going to call it my/an Indy jacket. It might not be the most SA but it's definitely close. Dark brown, leather, cargo pockets. Everyone will recognize it as one. It's akin to someone going into a leather store and picking out a brown leather jacket and calling it his Indy jacket even if it's even less SA.
This site is dedicated to people who care a lot about the differences, so forgive me if I'm a little annoyed. From his point on, I'll just ignore your posts in the spirit of goodwill...
But if you laterv insist that a baseball cap is almost the same thing as a fedora, there will be touble... ;-)
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Whatever it'll be my Indy jacket
Only we'll know the difference anyway
Only we'll know the difference anyway
Last edited by blueoakleyz on Sun Oct 26, 2008 8:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Vaderbreath
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 290
- Joined: Fri Feb 29, 2008 4:41 pm
- Location: Tri-Cities, WA
That's really a beautiful jacket you've picked out. It's a nice blend of Indy and flight jacket. Hey, call it whatever you want. My first "Indy" jacket looked just like that, and for me that was my Indy jacket. I've since started using a G&B Expedition because I like not having the cuffs and it's a very 'real world' jacket. I hope you love this jacket and if it brings out the Indy in you, then have fun and wear the heck out of it.
-Corey
-Corey
I don't see the A2 as an Indy jacket because it misses a lot of features an Indy jacket has. But I understand that you on the other hand see it as an Indy jacket because it was what it was based on.blueoakleyz wrote:Wow that's nitpicky
sorry but that's totally lame
The nitpicky you mentioned comes with the territory of this hobby: a big part of it is telling hats and or jackets appart from the 4 films, which is something most people can't do. Most of us here can tell a Raiders screenshot from a TOD screenshot from an LC screenshot from a CS screenshot just by looking at the jacket/hat, something George Lucas swears is impossible
So nitpicky is what we are and what most of us have become over here. Just a few months ago I couldn't tell the jackets appart, and a year ago I would have mistaken an A2 for an Indy jacket. Just by being here and learning things you get so trained in spotting the differences that you forget that it isn't obvious to everyone.
Regards, Geert
- WinstonWolf359
- Archaeologist
- Posts: 222
- Joined: Sun Mar 12, 2006 12:22 am
- Location: Fayetteville, NC
I'm confused.
You want a durable jacket, but what makes you think an Indy accurate jacket wouldn't be durable? There's a thread floating around on the first page of the jacket section of a ten-year-old Wested that looks amazing and is still in great shape, and will probably last another thirty years if it doesn't get drug behind a truck. As for features, I'm not aware of any difference in features between an A-2 and an Indy jacket. They're both leather, and have two sleeves and a zipper. What more do you need?
But you want a jacket that looks kinda like an Indy jacket, but isn't 100% accurate, so people won't think it IS an Indy jacket? I think the general public thinks EVERY brown leather jacket IS an Indy jacket or a Fonzie jacket, no matter WHAT the little details are.
Now I do understand the thinking of not going all out now if in a year's time this first jacket isn't going to fit you well, but if you're looking at spending $200-$300 on a leather jacket NOW what is the point? You're not saving any money by getting a less accurate jacket. You could spend $150 and get one of Todd's jackets that IS accurate and will undoubtedly last you the year or so until you are ready to get another jacket.
So um, yeah...Kinda confused.
You want a durable jacket, but what makes you think an Indy accurate jacket wouldn't be durable? There's a thread floating around on the first page of the jacket section of a ten-year-old Wested that looks amazing and is still in great shape, and will probably last another thirty years if it doesn't get drug behind a truck. As for features, I'm not aware of any difference in features between an A-2 and an Indy jacket. They're both leather, and have two sleeves and a zipper. What more do you need?
But you want a jacket that looks kinda like an Indy jacket, but isn't 100% accurate, so people won't think it IS an Indy jacket? I think the general public thinks EVERY brown leather jacket IS an Indy jacket or a Fonzie jacket, no matter WHAT the little details are.
Now I do understand the thinking of not going all out now if in a year's time this first jacket isn't going to fit you well, but if you're looking at spending $200-$300 on a leather jacket NOW what is the point? You're not saving any money by getting a less accurate jacket. You could spend $150 and get one of Todd's jackets that IS accurate and will undoubtedly last you the year or so until you are ready to get another jacket.
So um, yeah...Kinda confused.
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Well the nitpicky is understandable when you're in the realm of trying to get something actually SA. When you get a completely different class of coat and are just getting it as a casual coat that looks like Indy's.. it's more of a casual thing and nothing to be picky about. Like people are picky about the ribbons and bows on fedoras and I can understand that. If you are getting an Indy jacket that's supposed to be SA and something is 1/2" off from the original that's understandable too. I mean I can definitely tell the jackets apart between Raiders and Last Crusade with the bigger flaps and the extra buttons and the cut and fit etc.. But again that's within the realm of actual Indy jacketsgwyddion wrote:I don't see the A2 as an Indy jacket because it misses a lot of features an Indy jacket has. But I understand that you on the other hand see it as an Indy jacket because it was what it was based on.blueoakleyz wrote:Wow that's nitpicky
sorry but that's totally lame
The nitpicky you mentioned comes with the territory of this hobby: a big part of it is telling hats and or jackets appart from the 4 films, which is something most people can't do. Most of us here can tell a Raiders screenshot from a TOD screenshot from an LC screenshot from a CS screenshot just by looking at the jacket/hat, something George Lucas swears is impossible
So nitpicky is what we are and what most of us have become over here. Just a few months ago I couldn't tell the jackets appart, and a year ago I would have mistaken an A2 for an Indy jacket. Just by being here and learning things you get so trained in spotting the differences that you forget that it isn't obvious to everyone.
Regards, Geert
And lucas is insane, that should be a given
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
I could get an Indy jacket that's made from the same material. I'm not saying it wouldn't be durable. I'm saying that I'd like an Indy jacket for normal everyday wear but if I were to get an expensive jacket it would HAVE to have such and such features such as elastic cuffs.. so I'm just getting the next best thing so to speak as a trade off for what I like in a coat.WinstonWolf359 wrote:I'm confused.
You want a durable jacket, but what makes you think an Indy accurate jacket wouldn't be durable? There's a thread floating around on the first page of the jacket section of a ten-year-old Wested that looks amazing and is still in great shape, and will probably last another thirty years if it doesn't get drug behind a truck. As for features, I'm not aware of any difference in features between an A-2 and an Indy jacket. They're both leather, and have two sleeves and a zipper. What more do you need?
But you want a jacket that looks kinda like an Indy jacket, but isn't 100% accurate, so people won't think it IS an Indy jacket? I think the general public thinks EVERY brown leather jacket IS an Indy jacket or a Fonzie jacket, no matter WHAT the little details are.
Now I do understand the thinking of not going all out now if in a year's time this first jacket isn't going to fit you well, but if you're looking at spending $200-$300 on a leather jacket NOW what is the point? You're not saving any money by getting a less accurate jacket. You could spend $150 and get one of Todd's jackets that IS accurate and will undoubtedly last you the year or so until you are ready to get another jacket.
So um, yeah...Kinda confused.
It might be a small detail to those used to Indy cuffs but as I am a short it really bothers me to have sleeves hanging past my wrist. I could get it tailored but eh I like the elastic cuffs better.
But I'm not getting the jacket to have an Indy costume jacket I'm getting it to have an everyday leather jacket that everyone would think was Indy's.
I mean come on who WOULDN'T think that if I had that jacket on and a fedora
It's not to say though that I wouldn't want an Indy jacket as a costume piece too.. It's just not priority or sensible right now
I have a black "leather" jacket I got from walgreens for $50 that I call my Indy jacket right now..
the A-2 2000 will obviously be much closer
Believe me I was tempted to get the Indy one but I just can't deal with the sleeves
Why not create a concept indy costume while you're at it? In the concept drawings Indy wore an A2, so that would be a great idea even us gearheads could understand ;-)blueoakleyz wrote:But I'm not getting the jacket to have an Indy costume jacket I'm getting it to have an everyday leather jacket that everyone would think was Indy's.
Regards, Geert
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Lol I'd rather wait until I can spend $1000 on the most SA Indy jacket I can getgwyddion wrote:Why not create a concept indy costume while you're at it? In the concept drawings Indy wore an A2, so that would be a great idea even us gearheads could understand ;-)blueoakleyz wrote:But I'm not getting the jacket to have an Indy costume jacket I'm getting it to have an everyday leather jacket that everyone would think was Indy's.
Regards, Geert
Well, the only other thing I can think of that was different from how Indy looked on screen was a gunbelt with a strap that went over his shoulder. I could be wrong on this, but if you allready have pants and shirt allong that hat and the new A2, this would mean it wouldn't cost you that much to complete it ;-)blueoakleyz wrote:Lol I'd rather wait until I can spend $1000 on the most SA Indy jacket I can getgwyddion wrote:Why not create a concept indy costume while you're at it? In the concept drawings Indy wore an A2, so that would be a great idea even us gearheads could understand ;-)blueoakleyz wrote:But I'm not getting the jacket to have an Indy costume jacket I'm getting it to have an everyday leather jacket that everyone would think was Indy's.
Regards, Geert
Regards, Geert
-
- Field Surveyor
- Posts: 80
- Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2008 5:47 am
I don't think having some of the SA features are going to necessarily mean you can't wear the jacket in real life scenarios. It's NOT a halloween costume, but a well-crafted leather jacket, after all. I've head A leather jacket before and the thing was tough as ####, you could drag me behind a military vehicle and I'd wager it'd hold up! And that was just some dud I picked up at a thrift shop for $20, not a Wested. I'd seriously doubt if the thing's going to fall apart on you just because you made it SA a little more, know what I mean? I mean yeah some details like the zipper you might want to change or larger pockets so you can actually fit things in there, but on the whole?
I have the same worry as you in sizing but sort of in reverse- I plan on gaining 10-20 lbs of muscle in the next year, so I'm afraid of it being to SMALL if anything- if I have 16" biceps now, what do I do with my special ordered jacket when they're 17" or even 18" and the sleeves are too narrow? What if I go to a 46 chest and ordered a 42 or 44? Order larger now and deal with it being baggy for a year? But I'll have to take that chance and figure not being able to fit a jacket I spent a few hundred on is a small price to pay for being in better shape.
I have the same worry as you in sizing but sort of in reverse- I plan on gaining 10-20 lbs of muscle in the next year, so I'm afraid of it being to SMALL if anything- if I have 16" biceps now, what do I do with my special ordered jacket when they're 17" or even 18" and the sleeves are too narrow? What if I go to a 46 chest and ordered a 42 or 44? Order larger now and deal with it being baggy for a year? But I'll have to take that chance and figure not being able to fit a jacket I spent a few hundred on is a small price to pay for being in better shape.
For ****'s sake, an Indy Jacket is just like the 1930-50's leather utility jackets men used to wear. They had open cuffs and no silly woollen knits. They predate the A2 and are tough wearing real-life jackets, just like an Indy Jacket, which is really just a modern version of the utility jacket. The US Wings Indy jackets for instance are sold by the score to tradesmen.
- Chewbacca Jones
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3878
- Joined: Fri Jun 09, 2006 1:17 am
- Location: Somewhere in the vicinity of Betelgeuse
- Contact:
I think some are really missing blue's point here. He understands and likes the LOOK of the Indy jacket, but it's not the sort of thing he'd be comfortable wearing everyday. He wants to dress in the spirit of Indy, so he's compromising. Isn't that what this community is supposed to be about (at least in part). The spirit of Indiana Jones and adventure in general. Who gives a flying fez about an accurate gear piece if you aren't going to want to wear it!?! NOBODY should be throwing stones at this guy for wanting an A2 and being proud about it. Least of all on this forum. To paraphrase certain important powers on COW; people who walk around dressed like a fictional character should be careful about judging others.
-
- Field Surveyor
- Posts: 80
- Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2008 5:47 am
haha niiiceChewbacca Jones wrote: people who walk around dressed like a fictional character should be careful about judging others.
quite a valid point though. There are just two different SORTS around here, those who just want a 'like' jacket and those who want their jacket handed to them by harrison ford himself right off the set...so to speak. Personally I want a SA one, but I can't fault someone for going for the general look! There's something to be said about even having a brown leather jacket- I just don't see them often. At all. Around here anyway (WI). They always seem to be black if they're leather, and I never see front patch pockets.
You man up. Respect blue and the jacket he wants.Vegeta wrote:Yeah...thats nothin like an indy jacket...I dont care what you say. No elastic garbage...man up and get a real indy jacket.
I think the A-2 is a nice jacket. Order the jacket you want, blue and if it makes you feel like Indy, then call it your Indy jacket. Wear it in good health, buddy ;-)
- whipitgood
- Museum Curator
- Posts: 1203
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2008 7:16 pm
- Location: Los Angeles "A handsome devil in the city of angels."
I love A-2's, but would prefer an authentic one. I just keep getting outbid You can find great vintage A-2 style jackets all the time on Ebay. I had a couple over the years that were Hercules horsehides from the 40's & 50's and looked almost exactly like the real deal. They were still in great shape, durable and perfectly broken-in. The great thing was they only cost me $50 each. Get your A-2, but I say go vintage.
2 things. 1) I don't have any Indiana Jones costume items - just the jacket because it looks cool with jeans. Not all of us wear costumes.Chewbacca Jones wrote:I To paraphrase certain important powers on COW; people who walk around dressed like a fictional character should be careful about judging others.
2) To me Blue appears arrogant and somewhat disrespectful to the hobby here. I think he would be better served on a different site where A2's are popular and where he can explore the general 1930's adventuring gear that he appears content with.
But that's just my opinion... and I'm happy to express it.
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Is having a laugh?
I have NO interest in A2s or classic or era specific jackets. It's not a hobby for me. It's just an Indy jacket. It's leather, it's brown, it has cargo pockets and tons about it are just like Indy's. It just happens to be a jacket I'd feel comfortable in.
I'm not trying to talk for everyone here but I doubt most people take this as a serious hobby that should be respected as some holy object.. Wanting an Indy jacket that isn't SA isn't disrespectful
I have NO interest in A2s or classic or era specific jackets. It's not a hobby for me. It's just an Indy jacket. It's leather, it's brown, it has cargo pockets and tons about it are just like Indy's. It just happens to be a jacket I'd feel comfortable in.
I'm not trying to talk for everyone here but I doubt most people take this as a serious hobby that should be respected as some holy object.. Wanting an Indy jacket that isn't SA isn't disrespectful
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
You're being ridiculousCM wrote:Blue, with responses like that I'm just going to continue assuming you're a practical joker who is taking the ****. Have fun.
I'm not ordering a nonSA jacket just to tick you off.
I'm ordering a jacket *I* like so I can feel like I'm Indy in my childish mind while still having a great everyday jacket.
This is all for fun
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Well, I ordered a goat as part of the "special" that Wested offers, along with the shirt and pants. I guess because it's made in India (at a cheaper rate maybe?), they automatically put shoulder pads on everything that goes out of their country... Leather jackets, blouses, ties, rugs, curry, goats, curried goats, etc.
Yes... They sew shoulder pads onto their curried goats too.
Maybe just suggest that you'd rather not have the pads, to make sure they don't install them. For the custom jackets, they may not even do it.
Yes... They sew shoulder pads onto their curried goats too.
Maybe just suggest that you'd rather not have the pads, to make sure they don't install them. For the custom jackets, they may not even do it.
- conceited_ape
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 741
- Joined: Mon Jul 29, 2002 2:48 am
- Location: Melbourne, Australia
blueoakleyz wrote:I'm ordering a jacket *I* like so I can feel like I'm Indy in my childish mind while still having a great everyday jacket.
This is all for fun
Soo... then why not, with all the available resources here, actually buy an INDY jacket? Get an off-the-rack Wested if you're not fussed about SA. At least that way it's still an INDY jacket. I mean, here you are at the world's foremost Jones outfit resourse hub, declaring you're about to order an 'INDY' jacket (your words), and you want something that doesn't even come close?!
I've gotta agree with CM on this. Just seems a little nonsensical. But hey, it's your money.
- Chewbacca Jones
- Legendary Adventurer
- Posts: 3878
- Joined: Fri Jun 09, 2006 1:17 am
- Location: Somewhere in the vicinity of Betelgeuse
- Contact:
Seems to me that you are the one being disrespectful... TO A MEMBER! (People first, dude) And terribly inhospitable, too boot. You're pretty much showing him the door over the fact that he's more comfortable with an A2! OMG! He likes elastic cuffs! That's a bit over the top.CM wrote:) To me Blue appears arrogant and somewhat disrespectful to the hobby here. I think he would be better served on a different site where A2's are popular and where he can explore the general 1930's adventuring gear that he appears content with.
I think your opinion is clear on the subject at hand. How about toning it down or backing off, now? Let's keep it civilized and gentlemanly (and gentlewomanly). He stated his reasons that a "true Indy jacket" won't due, and they make sense. Let's concentrate on advice concerning the jacket style he has chosen.
NO SHOULDER PADS!!! Other than that; enjoy.
After re-reading some of the comments up above, all I can think of is an episode of Seinfeld where George is trying to impress a girl, but he doen't want to let her know w ht he really does for a living.
So Jerry suggests he lie about his career and say he's an architect or something, instead.
So George says, "Hmmph. I always wanted to pretend to be an Architect."
Sorry... The talk about wanting an Indy Jacket that "looks" like and Indy jacket, made me think of that.
I have no opinion, in either direction.
Except for redheads. I'm leaning towards redheads. ;-)
So Jerry suggests he lie about his career and say he's an architect or something, instead.
So George says, "Hmmph. I always wanted to pretend to be an Architect."
Sorry... The talk about wanting an Indy Jacket that "looks" like and Indy jacket, made me think of that.
I have no opinion, in either direction.
Except for redheads. I'm leaning towards redheads. ;-)
Calm down there, Partner... I'm entitled to my opinion and I wouldn't dream of showing him the door. I thought Blue might be better served on another site given his unusual (for this site) preferences. I was trying to help the guy, okay? I thought he wanted more info on A2's and needed some quality information on that particular choice. Then I figured he was taking the **** I must have read him wrong. Now I don't know or especially care. I'll say no more abotu it since I've already made my points.Chewbacca Jones wrote:Seems to me that you are the one being disrespectful... TO A MEMBER! (People first, dude) And terribly inhospitable, too boot. You're pretty much showing him the door over the fact that he's more comfortable with an A2! OMG! He likes elastic cuffs! That's a bit over the top.CM wrote:) To me Blue appears arrogant and somewhat disrespectful to the hobby here. I think he would be better served on a different site where A2's are popular and where he can explore the general 1930's adventuring gear that he appears content with.
I think your opinion is clear on the subject at hand. How about toning it down or backing off, now? Let's keep it civilized and gentlemanly (and gentlewomanly). He stated his reasons that a "true Indy jacket" won't due, and they make sense. Let's concentrate on advice concerning the jacket style he has chosen.
NO SHOULDER PADS!!! Other than that; enjoy.
Cheers
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Ok first of all some of you are taking this too seriously. If you are just trying to help me with my jacket buying that's fine but don't say I can't call it an Indy jacket..
Doesn't come close is reeeally stretching it. Look at this comparison pic and tell me it doesn't come close
Because I'm not buying it for halloween I'm buying it for the winter and everyday jacket use. I don't want to wear a jacket like that that doesn't have elastic cuffs and nice side pockets.conceited_ape wrote:blueoakleyz wrote:I'm ordering a jacket *I* like so I can feel like I'm Indy in my childish mind while still having a great everyday jacket.
This is all for fun
Soo... then why not, with all the available resources here, actually buy an INDY jacket? Get an off-the-rack Wested if you're not fussed about SA. At least that way it's still an INDY jacket. I mean, here you are at the world's foremost Jones outfit resourse hub, declaring you're about to order an 'INDY' jacket (your words), and you want something that doesn't even come close?!
I've gotta agree with CM on this. Just seems a little nonsensical. But hey, it's your money.
Doesn't come close is reeeally stretching it. Look at this comparison pic and tell me it doesn't come close
- conceited_ape
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 741
- Joined: Mon Jul 29, 2002 2:48 am
- Location: Melbourne, Australia
A hobby like this really sharpens the eye, believe me. Ten years ago I'd have said, 'sure they're practically the same', but with all i've seen and learned over the years, all I can say is that they're both... brown. I cant un-know what I know in this case, but if you're happy getting a jacket like that in reference to Indiana Jones, then have at it and enjoy. I don't understand it personally, but you don't need me to. ;-)
Gonna chime in and agree with everyone else here as well. That jacket might as well be blue! Apples and oranges. What you should have done is gone to the MacGuyver forum for advice if you are planning on buying that jacket!!
Seriously, that photo didn't prove your point. Thos jackets are nothing alike.
I'm not saying it isn't a nice jacket though. I'm sure you'll love it. Looks good!
Seriously, that photo didn't prove your point. Thos jackets are nothing alike.
I'm not saying it isn't a nice jacket though. I'm sure you'll love it. Looks good!
I have the goatskin Indy US Wings jacket.....I got it for 2 reasons 1) Halloween, but since there was a mix up with payment, my whip didn't come so I'm not going as Indy this year...anyways...2nd reason I got my Indy USWings goatskin jacket is because I wanted a REAL jacket that looked like Indy's. Lemme tell you so far in 40degree heavy winds this jacket holds up and you don't have that stupid elastic cloth anywhere. I dunno why you want an A2 jacket and calling it an Indy jacket but at the same time you're not getting one, the Indy style USWings jackets are the best for durability and real life wear as well as real Indy look.
- Tennessee Smith
- Site Admin
- Posts: 10582
- Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2007 3:47 pm
- Location: Everything we need is right here.
- blueoakleyz
- Dig Leader
- Posts: 628
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:57 am
Because I LIKE elastic cuffs? and otherwise it's just the same as Indy's to me.Gunk wrote:I have the goatskin Indy US Wings jacket.....I got it for 2 reasons 1) Halloween, but since there was a mix up with payment, my whip didn't come so I'm not going as Indy this year...anyways...2nd reason I got my Indy USWings goatskin jacket is because I wanted a REAL jacket that looked like Indy's. Lemme tell you so far in 40degree heavy winds this jacket holds up and you don't have that stupid elastic cloth anywhere. I dunno why you want an A2 jacket and calling it an Indy jacket but at the same time you're not getting one, the Indy style USWings jackets are the best for durability and real life wear as well as real Indy look.
I finally think I grasp the nonsense that is this thread. Blue wants to buy a jacket. It is probably a very good jacket. It will make him very happy. His only mistake was even stopping by this forum because if you are going to start a thread on an Indy forum, saying you are going to order an Indy jacket, one would THINK that was your intention.
It is clear that blue does not want an Indy jacket. The jacket he has chosen and the pics he has shown are proof enough of that. Because of this, I don't really know what he is looking for from the members here.
Blue, the jacket you are looking at, while absolutely not an Indy jacket, is nice and I'm sure you will enjoy it. I'm just not sure what it is you want from the members of this forum. If you want to talk about Indy jackets, you are in the right place. If you want to talk about the jacket you are going to buy, you are probably not (like I said earlier, maybe a MacGuyver forum).
Enjoy your jacket, and be secure in the knowledge that nobody will think you are trying to look like Indy. Based on what you have said you want in a jacket, I think you are making the right choice.
It is clear that blue does not want an Indy jacket. The jacket he has chosen and the pics he has shown are proof enough of that. Because of this, I don't really know what he is looking for from the members here.
Blue, the jacket you are looking at, while absolutely not an Indy jacket, is nice and I'm sure you will enjoy it. I'm just not sure what it is you want from the members of this forum. If you want to talk about Indy jackets, you are in the right place. If you want to talk about the jacket you are going to buy, you are probably not (like I said earlier, maybe a MacGuyver forum).
Enjoy your jacket, and be secure in the knowledge that nobody will think you are trying to look like Indy. Based on what you have said you want in a jacket, I think you are making the right choice.
-
- Field Surveyor
- Posts: 80
- Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2008 5:47 am
Well said, Sir. Excellent points. Blue posting here is like an IBM enthusiast posting on a Mac forum. They're the same because they are both computers, right....?maboot38 wrote:I finally think I grasp the nonsense that is this thread. Blue wants to buy a jacket. It is probably a very good jacket. It will make him very happy. His only mistake was even stopping by this forum because if you are going to start a thread on an Indy forum, saying you are going to order an Indy jacket, one would THINK that was your intention.
It is clear that blue does not want an Indy jacket. The jacket he has chosen and the pics he has shown are proof enough of that. Because of this, I don't really know what he is looking for from the members here.
Blue, the jacket you are looking at, while absolutely not an Indy jacket, is nice and I'm sure you will enjoy it. I'm just not sure what it is you want from the members of this forum. If you want to talk about Indy jackets, you are in the right place. If you want to talk about the jacket you are going to buy, you are probably not (like I said earlier, maybe a MacGuyver forum).
Enjoy your jacket, and be secure in the knowledge that nobody will think you are trying to look like Indy. Based on what you have said you want in a jacket, I think you are making the right choice.
- scot2525
- Professor of Archaeology
- Posts: 760
- Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 9:56 pm
- Location: Northeast of Indy
"Nuff said"CM wrote:Well said, Sir. Excellent points. Blue posting here is like an IBM enthusiast posting on a Mac forum. They're the same because they are both computers, right....?maboot38 wrote:I finally think I grasp the nonsense that is this thread. Blue wants to buy a jacket. It is probably a very good jacket. It will make him very happy. His only mistake was even stopping by this forum because if you are going to start a thread on an Indy forum, saying you are going to order an Indy jacket, one would THINK that was your intention.
It is clear that blue does not want an Indy jacket. The jacket he has chosen and the pics he has shown are proof enough of that. Because of this, I don't really know what he is looking for from the members here.
Blue, the jacket you are looking at, while absolutely not an Indy jacket, is nice and I'm sure you will enjoy it. I'm just not sure what it is you want from the members of this forum. If you want to talk about Indy jackets, you are in the right place. If you want to talk about the jacket you are going to buy, you are probably not (like I said earlier, maybe a MacGuyver forum).
Enjoy your jacket, and be secure in the knowledge that nobody will think you are trying to look like Indy. Based on what you have said you want in a jacket, I think you are making the right choice.
Stan Lee