
I'm not here to take a position as such, but simply to provide choices. Viable options and quality value for your hard-earned money.

Moderators: Indiana Jeff, Mike, Indydawg
The fact that a stunt jacket is worn by the hero character, doesn't turn it into a HERO JACKET.Texan Scott wrote:Of course, the buying decision is subjective, weighing all the factors, etc. While some of it is informing. The three stunt jackets of the third order saw screen time and saw time on the man's back as well. They were made to be exact copies of the hero jacket from the first order.
And Tony told me directly while making my jacket that the screen-used jacket he copied "was a #### piece of ####." So, I guess that means if you want a TRULY SA jacket, it's gotta be a quickly made, wonky piece of poo. So, those of you that have a fantastically made Nowak don't really have SA jackets!HWaltonJonesJr.Phd wrote:SA= screen accurate. TN copied a SCREEN-USED jacket. That's where I go for SA.
Thanks for the correction. But I was only $50 off. I recalled that Riley raised the price of the CS once or twice since taking over the biz.BendingOak wrote: and thats what I paid for my Raiders 747. I think some are blowing the price increase out of whack for some reason.
AH! So... was made by PETER after all...uh?binkmeisterRick wrote:And Tony told me directly while making my jacket that the screen-used jacket he copied "was a #### piece of ####." So, I guess that means if you want a TRULY SA jacket, it's gotta be a quickly made, wonky piece of poo.HWaltonJonesJr.Phd wrote:SA= screen accurate. TN copied a SCREEN-USED jacket. That's where I go for SA.
I won't argue with you, Diego, but here is what the Main Site says:Indiego Jones wrote:The fact that a stunt jacket is worn by the hero character, doesn't turn it into a HERO JACKET.Texan Scott wrote:Of course, the buying decision is subjective, weighing all the factors, etc. While some of it is informing. The three stunt jackets of the third order saw screen time and saw time on the man's back as well. They were made to be exact copies of the hero jacket from the first order.
A HERO JACKET has different purposes and detail accuracy than a STUNT JACKET.
A stunt jacket, for ex., has more room for paddings, and press studs and rings are removed in order to avoid stuntman's injuries during filming. So, pockets and sidestraps are sewed on leather.
A HERO jacket is created for fitting correctly the main actor, to make him look good.
A HERO jacket looks different from a STUNT jacket, in terms of details and proportions.-
Yes, I interpret identical in the same way you do.Texan Scott wrote:I won't argue with you, Diego, but here is what the Main Site says:Indiego Jones wrote:The fact that a stunt jacket is worn by the hero character, doesn't turn it into a HERO JACKET.Texan Scott wrote:Of course, the buying decision is subjective, weighing all the factors, etc. While some of it is informing. The three stunt jackets of the third order saw screen time and saw time on the man's back as well. They were made to be exact copies of the hero jacket from the first order.
A HERO JACKET has different purposes and detail accuracy than a STUNT JACKET.
A stunt jacket, for ex., has more room for paddings, and press studs and rings are removed in order to avoid stuntman's injuries during filming. So, pockets and sidestraps are sewed on leather.
A HERO jacket is created for fitting correctly the main actor, to make him look good.
A HERO jacket looks different from a STUNT jacket, in terms of details and proportions.-
"Order #3. Three “spares” ordered after reviewing the script, and more specifically for the needs of the stunt crew. Because of the variations in Order #2, it was decided to ask for three additional jackets “made identical to the prototype” that would then be held aside for each of the three principal stunt doubles—Terry Leonard, Vic Armstrong and Martin Grace. As production began, this plan fell somewhat by the wayside, with only Grace wearing his jacket during the Elstree shooting. Leonard and Armstrong kept their jackets as souvenirs. Grace’s jacket from Elstree became the de facto “hero” jacket during the filming in Hawaii. "
I interpret "identical" to mean identical.
Texan Scott wrote:Call or email him and ask for the samples. That is the best way for you to make that determination. I don't know how many times i was leaning toward a hide, then changed my mind when I received the samples. But this is something only you can know from the samples you recieve....and I woudn't decide before I had them in hand, if that is of any help?
I concur with all you discribed, except that goat can also be shininig like lamb, it depends the kind of finishing the tannery do.Solo4114 wrote:Texan Scott wrote:Call or email him and ask for the samples. That is the best way for you to make that determination. I don't know how many times i was leaning toward a hide, then changed my mind when I received the samples. But this is something only you can know from the samples you recieve....and I woudn't decide before I had them in hand, if that is of any help?
I plan to, yeah.
To the best of everyone's knowledge here, are the differences I described above accurate? Or am I mixing up my materials?
What gospel is that? I don't think anyone here has outright said (at least in this post) that TN created any original Indy jackets or some of the other jackets. Yes its been confirmed Tony copied a LC jacket, and then made improvements to that pattern for the CS jacket. Tony copied the Raiders jacket, thats a well known fact as well. I do believe the Surrogates was Tony's design. So we are buying a copy of a jacket, most people would tend to agree to that fact. Even Magnoli's offering copies of jackets, or even Todd's Indy jacket is a copy, and they are all quality jackets from both vendors. I'm sure many other vendors out there offer copies of jackets too. I'm really not understanding where the "copying" comes into play here?_ wrote:The faithful are creating gospel that is false...
Actually, a custom Wested would be £165, which would equate to roughly $260, (without shipping) so not as much as you might have thought. And if you were after a slightly tougher leather then the soft goat would be my choice. Tougher than the lamb, and almost as soft and light. That's what I went for when I went to Wested to get a Raiders jacket earlier this year. jmoSolo4114 wrote:My issue is one of value, not price. I can save the money to pay for a TN jacket. Might take a bit, but I can do it. The question is then what value I get out of it, as compared to other options, and taking into account the rest of my life and where my money needs to go (and where I want it to go).
In general terms, I'm willing to spend more money up front to get a better, longer-lasting product that is tailored to me.
Example: I've had my Wested since, oh, 2001. It's lasted pretty well (well, except for an incident with an over-curious kitten...), but I'm not as happy with how it's worn over time, and the liner's shot. Replacing a liner wouldn't be cheap, so if I'm in for a penny on the liner, why not in for a pound on a new jacket? Another Wested would be around, what, $300-500? Something like that, I figure (haven't checked their site in a while), and that's for an off-the-rack jacket with probably comparable quality leather. If I'm spending that much for a lower-end (not bad, just lower end), jacket, why not go all-in and get something that will look great, be tailored to my measurements (I can get my suit jacket measurements from a tailor who's made several suits for me), and will be made of what's likely more durable leather? So, if that means I shell out $1K, well, I'll bite the bullet and do that, figuring that I'll be buying a jacket that'll last me 20+ years and be tailored to me, instead of periodically buying off-the-rack jackets for a lower price.
That's just my calculus, though. I don't claim to speak for any objective standard of sanity. Also, I've gone back and forth over this as other issues have popped up (IE: car needed a new clutch this summer....ouch).
Can't say it any better than what was said right here. Anything you read here can and will be subjective to the opinion of the writer. Go to the source.BendingOak wrote: My advise to you solo. Is to go straight to the source and ask him all your question. As someone told me here. You can't go by 2nd hand information. Take scotts advise and ask for samp,e swatches from Riley. He's a nice guy, very helpful and very easy to work with.
John
You did, there wasn't, I'll take your word for it, I've heard the same things, and...your opinion IS welcome...Solo asked about a Nowak and I gave my opinion. I don't see nothing wrong with it. I have owned a few different labels and have seen others ( first hand). Looks to me more than you have. I'm also something of a craftsmen myself , or at least some have told me. I think my opinion would be welcomed.
_ wrote:Yep... Only 30%-50% depending on how honest you are...BendingOak wrote:Since we are giving our opinions. I'll give mine. His prices didn't go way up up up. They did go up but not by that much. If you want the high quality of a custome made jacket no one else comes close to a Nowak.That's a fact - not an opinion...
And if you don't own anything else, you really can't slam them - can you?
It's nice that you love your jacket, John - but you might want to keep things real...
Solo4114 wrote:But just think.
What if he IS in your closet?
RIGHT NOW??
I've owned one Wested lamb ca. 2002, one G&B Expo in goat ca. 2003, one G&B Expo in lamb ca. 2005, one Todd's standard lamb ca. 2008 (briefly before returning it), and one TN Raiders in 747 cow ca. 2009.Solo4114 wrote:I'll likely end up doing that.
Can anyone here comment on quality comparisons -- in terms of durability of both the leather and how it's all put together -- among the various major jacket sources? Anyone had any particular problems with this or that type of leather or this or that jacket-maker's offering?
Religious experience? Closer than most might think really. It is an epiphany to discover that if you broaden your horizons, you will find that there is not a single jacket god. There are many, many manufacturers (most unknown) who make outrageously awesome jackets depending on what your tastes are. Too many people are not willing to accept that there are others besides the one they worship. That is how wars start. If you opens your mind a little you can be like a kid in a candy store. Of course, you will also be opening your wallet too. See, just like church..._ wrote:I did have a religious experience during the QM. I went to Bates. (queue angelic chorus) I saw the T2 jacket Arnold wore. I saw The prototype "shooter" jacket from T3. I saw all the sketches snd notes for T3. I saw some fxxxgxn cool custom jackets with amazing detail.